search

crossbario / crossbar

Crossbar.io - WAMP application router
https://crossbar.io/
Other
2.05k stars 274 forks source link

forum.crossbar.io closed intentionally? #2001

Closed readingtype closed 2 years ago

readingtype commented 2 years ago

Hi

I notice the forum is no longer available and I wonder if it is going to go back online.

I'm having a bit of trouble with running the code in /crossbar-examples/authentication/wampcra/static and I was hoping to use historical posts to help me debug. Of course this is not the only way. I can see recent changes in the config.json and I will look at the commit history.

My current error is:

crossbar.common.checkconfig.InvalidConfigException: WAMP-Anonymous configuration - encountered unknown attribute 'realm'

but this would be a different ticket :-)

Thanks, Ben

readingtype commented 2 years ago

Hi

I found the secondary bug: the example code is too new for the crossbar version installed by pip today (22.3.1). Put it another way, 22.3.1 does not accept 'realm' as part of the specification of an anonymous transport.

It's always difficult to keep sample code in sync with published code -- could I suggest pip freeze -r /crossbar-examples/requirements.txt -- or (not very palatable) make the examples into a package?

Ben

om26er commented 2 years ago

The new forum now lives at https://crossbar.discourse.group/, please direct your queries there.

readingtype commented 2 years ago

@om26er Thank you very much!

oberstet commented 2 years ago

It's always difficult to keep sample code in sync with published code

yes, it is, in particular given the number of features and combinations - we're working on more automated tests.

fwiw, what you've run into: anonymous auth without a realm, by having the realm specified in the anonymous authenticator, yeah, that is quite new in crossbar, and we should add that feature as a test to https://github.com/crossbario/crossbar-examples/tree/master/authentication#test

these authentication tests are also quite new, and run automated, and hence we might even run them as part of CI ..

readingtype commented 2 years ago

@oberstet Thank you.

I am pushing my luck a bit, I know, but could you suggest a release version that you think will work with the example code? I cannot easily fix the problem I reported in this ticket by upgrading Crossbar since that code has not reached this repository yet. I noticed some other issues (eg changes in Werkzeug 2.1 that break imports) which also make running the examples non-trivial.

Ben

bytebuff commented 2 years ago

Please change the forum address of your official website to the latest one！

readingtype commented 2 years ago

@ScrapingBoot I found out that (depending on where you look) it has already changed. For example, the markdown documentation source in the examples repository has the new forum link in HEAD whereas the checked-out HTML page does not. So it is presumably working its way gradually from the dev team to the wider world...