search

cryptonomex / graphene-ui

Cryptonomex Graphene front end (wallet and decentralized exchange)
https://bitshares.openledger.info
MIT License
156 stars 100 forks source link

What's wrong? Multi signature transactions do not perform? #870

Closed imYao closed 8 years ago

imYao commented 8 years ago

https://s19.postimg.org/qyc6msqab/What_s_wrong_with_Multi_sig_01.png

https://s19.postimg.org/iu42i23v7/What_s_wrong_with_Multi_sig_02.png

svk31 commented 8 years ago

I had a look, the operation is missing the owner approval of the account 1.2.116524 which is bbpingji.

image

That should not be the case though, so I think there must be a bug in the witness_node since bbpingji is not included in the owner auths of the account.

image

svk31 commented 8 years ago

Thanks to @xeroc the mystery has been resolved! My previous assumptions were incorrect, I forgot that the proposal object does not contain recursive required approvals, only the top level account even if it's a multi-sig account as in this case.

The actual issue was simply that the account bbpingji did not have sufficient BTS to pay the fee for the transaction! Once xeroc transfered 1 BTS to the account, the proposed transaction executed as expected.

This information isn't readily available but I'll see if I can add an indication to the UI that the account has insufficient fees.

svk31 commented 8 years ago

Closing this and creating a new more specific issue.

xeroc commented 8 years ago

The actual issue was simply that the account bbpingji did not have sufficient BTS to pay the fee for the transaction! Once xeroc transfered 1 BTS to the account, the proposed transaction executed as expected.

As a remark, after transferring the 1 BTS to the account, the proposal would not have executed automatically before reaching the expiration time at which time the network would have tried a last time to execute. Then it would have succeeded since sufficient funds were available.

In your case, I transferred 1 BTS to the account and added my approval to the proposal which made the proposal re-evaluate and execute.