search

cs2103aug2014-w10-4j / main

ChirpTask
3 stars 1 forks source link

When you edit a task which is done, the task becomes undone. #119

Closed quanyang closed 9 years ago

quanyang commented 9 years ago

@cs2103aug2014-w10-4j/developers Is this expected or a bug?

HaLinhh commented 9 years ago

I think it can be expected. If it is done the user might not bother to edit, I think.

quanyang commented 9 years ago

@HaLinhh Just for clarification, this isn't something that we think is expected. By expected it means that this characteristic is done on purpose. You can't think that you do something on purpose.

newbishme commented 9 years ago

when was this implemented? and who implemented this? we didn't discuss this behaviour. should be left as done. @HaLinhh @quanyang

quanyang commented 9 years ago

@newbishme I think it's an accidental behaviour.

pyonghe commented 9 years ago

I think is because inputparser did not check whether old task is done/undone.

pyonghe commented 9 years ago

@cs2103aug2014-w10-4j/developers Why would user want to edit a done task? By accident? Logically speaking if user edited a done task, means task should be undone. But nonetheless, this is an accidental bug and we should handle this asap.