search

cstb / citygml-energy

CityGML Energy ADE
41 stars 9 forks source link

GasStorageSystem #126

Closed kwakuwulf closed 7 years ago

kwakuwulf commented 7 years ago

As discussed in Vienna I'm adding some issues from the viewpoint of industrial process modelling:

Waste water treatment plants may even have GasStorageSystems from sludge treatment (biogas). Attributes:

kwakuwulf commented 7 years ago

This may be rather something for the UtilityNetworkADE

RomainNouvel commented 7 years ago

The border between EnergyADE and UtilityNetworkADE is actually a long recurrent topic... Our last agreement was that the border is approx. the "end of the garden". Then DistrictHeatSubstation may be integrated in the Energy ADE, but network and heating/power plants belongs to UtilityNetwork

kwakuwulf commented 7 years ago

I understand. I see it from the viewpoint of a WWTP (waste water treatment plant) which has energy demands like other industries and households and should thus be defineable in the EnergyADE. Gas production is a side product of the WWTP which can similarly be defined as waste energy (just in the form of biogas). So from this point of view the WWTP is rather a consumer with waste energy than a utility that has the main purpose of delivering energy to utility networks.

mlauster commented 7 years ago

This is still in discussion with UtilityNetworkADE and will be re-opened if the decision is to integrate it in Energy ADE