search

cta-wave / dpctf-tests

Repo for DPCTF Tests. We prefer to keep the Tests separated from Test Runner
Other
1 stars 5 forks source link

Enhancing usability for end-user. #171

Closed Lis-TV closed 4 months ago

Lis-TV commented 5 months ago

Propose to include set of commands and steps to allow deploy HbbTV tests branch, to have fully operational solution. Assume the starting point is that the user is inside dpctf-deploy folder, with running docker image ( successful installation dpcf-deploy project). The starting point:

python3 -m pip install six python3 -m pip install isodate git clone -b hbbtv-tests https://github.com/cta-wave/dpctf-tests ....

jpiesing commented 5 months ago

Propose to include set of commands and steps to allow deploy HbbTV tests branch, to have fully operational solution. Assume the starting point is that the user is inside dpctf-deploy folder, with running docker image ( successful installation dpcf-deploy project). The starting point:

python3 -m pip install six python3 -m pip install isodate git clone -b hbbtv-tests https://github.com/cta-wave/dpctf-tests ....

The current preference is to point people at the dpctf-deploy repo. Only real power users and rocket scientists should run tests from dpctf-tests. IMHO the only reason for a normal user to install dpctf-tests is if they need to examine the code and work out what's going on.

FritzHeiden commented 5 months ago

To use the hbbtv tests branch use the corresponding parameter when building the image:

./build.sh master latest --tests-branch hbbtv
Lis-TV commented 5 months ago

dpctf-deploy works fine, however it carries all CTA tests. I am looking for a way to allow people find, configure and use HbbTV test set in convenient way. For testing guys usage git is a problem... Fritz - the command is fine, but it is not implicitly mentioned in dpctf-deploy, people even dont know that there is hbbtv branch. Fritz, is it possible to create document/paragraph in dpctf-deploy with HbbTV specific set of commands? After that we could add link to it on our systems (Redmine, Test spec, tech.cta.wave* XML files, link in https://www.hbbtv.org/resource-library ) to

jpiesing commented 5 months ago

dpctf-deploy works fine, however it carries all CTA tests. I am looking for a way to allow people find, configure and use HbbTV test set in convenient way. For testing guys usage git is a problem... Fritz - the command is fine, but it is not implicitly mentioned in dpctf-deploy, people even dont know that there is hbbtv branch. Fritz, is it possible to create document/paragraph in dpctf-deploy with HbbTV specific set of commands? After that we could add link to it on our systems (Redmine, Test spec, tech.cta.wave* XML files, link in https://www.hbbtv.org/resource-library ) to

The HbbTV branch is not maintained. IMHO it was a transient feature for the last plugfest. People shouldn't know it exists.

EDIT: We have a test runner issue for making it easier to run subsets of tests. https://github.com/cta-wave/dpctf-test-runner/issues/47

FritzHeiden commented 4 months ago

EDIT: We have a test runner issue for making it easier to run subsets of tests. cta-wave/dpctf-test-runner#47

This has an implementation with hbbtv subset: https://github.com/cta-wave/dpctf-test-runner/issues/47#issuecomment-2104843583

jpiesing commented 4 months ago

The underlying issue of making it easier for people to use the HbbTV tests is addressed in a different way as explained above.

I think the original proposal is "WONTFIX". There is no interest in making it easier for people to use dpctf-tests directly avoiding dpctf-deploy.

I think this one can be closed.

jpiesing commented 4 months ago

2024-05-14: Closed on the basis of the recent work by @FritzHeiden