search

cta-wave / mezzanine

This repo contains scripts that will build annotated test content from specific source content, compatible with the WAVE device playback test suite.
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
2 stars 2 forks source link

Changes to mezzanine source content to make it easier to check lipsync? #27

Closed nicholas-fr closed 3 years ago

nicholas-fr commented 3 years ago

We currently have content from 2 sources: Tears of Steel and Croatia.

ToS has plenty of dialogue, Croatia has none (or only barely audible discussions in the background, with no visible faces). We've been using ToS for 15/30/60fps content and Croatia for the 12.5/25/50fps content.

Q1. Do we continue using the same part of ToS, or do we select a part with more dialogue to make it easier to visually check AV sync / lipsync?

Q2. Do we use Croatia for 12.5/25/50fps content even though it has no dialogue, and if not what alternative content should we use?

In my opinion, with the added AV sync flash+beep, what we're currently using is fine.

The aim of this issue is to gather any different opinions on this topic, before making a decision. To hopefully avoid the need for any changes to the mezzanine source content later on. In particular, if there's a preference for using a different part of ToS, we can do that without too much trouble. If you think Croatia is not suitable, then please propose an alternative.

nicholas-fr commented 3 years ago

No comments, will continue mezzanine creation using the current source content.