search

culturecreates / artsdata-planet-wikidata

Pipelines with Wikidata
0 stars 0 forks source link

CDA Issue: linking Assemblée canadienne de la danse's ID #1

Open fjjulien opened 1 week ago

fjjulien commented 1 week ago

In the CDA organizations dataset, the record for wd:Q71859269 (L’Assemblée canadienne de la danse) did not have an Artsdata ID.

Having double-checked that no Artsdata ID had been minted for either "Assemblée canadienne de la danse" nor "Canadian Dance Assembly", I minted the ID from the dataset (on behalf of the Artsdata authority). This newly minted entity however only had a French name.

Then, I attempted to mint from Wikidata to retrieve and hopefully add the English name. However, in step 2 of the minting, the reconciliation process failed to find http://kg.artsdata.ca/resource/K4-207.

This suggests that the reconciliation from Wikidata:

  1. Is only attempting a reconciliation based on the English Wikidata label; and,
  2. Is not reconciling against Wikidata URIs already linked as sameAs.

In the short-term, can you please make sure that http://kg.artsdata.ca/resource/K4-207 is given a proper English label?

In the medium-term, can we solve the reconciliation issue I encountered.

saumier commented 1 week ago

@fjjulien I have added the English label to K4-207

saumier commented 1 week ago

Then, I attempted to mint from Wikidata to retrieve and hopefully add the English name.

This would not have added data. You can only create new entities from Wikidata.

This suggests that the reconciliation from Wikidata:

Is only attempting a reconciliation based on the English Wikidata label; and, Is not reconciling against Wikidata URIs already linked as sameAs.

The reason why K4-207 was not found is because the reconciliation service was sent only the first label which can be either fr of en. I will modify the code to send both en and fr labels.