search

cwrc / ontology

CWRC ontology - primary repository
13 stars 7 forks source link

other-reported --> reported #338

Closed SusanBrown closed 6 years ago

SusanBrown commented 6 years ago

I think it would be clearer and less clunky if we drop "other".

So: has gender (could be self-defined or not or unknown) has gender (self-reported) has gender (reported)

[cwrc:hasGender cwrc:hasGenderSelfReported cwrc:hasGenderReported]

I think this works. Wdyt @lemaka @antimony27 @JasmineDW ?

alliyya commented 6 years ago

I can start creating these *Reported Properties and modifying labels? @SusanBrown ex. uri: cwrc:hasGender label: has gender --> has gender (could be self-reported or not or unknown) definition: Describes a person's gender. As with other @@#CulturalForm@@s, an individual may have more than one property or descriptor of this type. For further information about this property, see @@#Gender@@

I'm not sure if you want to also modify the definitions as well

uri: cwrc:hasGenderReported label: has gender (reported) definition: This indicates a person's reported gender. For more information on this property, see @@#Gender@@.

also deprecation of personalProperties

SusanBrown commented 6 years ago

Don’t modify has gender to add parentheses. The definition should make the possibilities clear but we don’t want a huge label. So the definition could read Describes a person’s gender, which may be self-reported or reported by another.

alliyya commented 6 years ago

uri: cwrc:hasGender label: has gender definition: Describes a person's gender, which may be self-reported or reported by another. As with other @@#CulturalForm@@s, an individual may have more than one property or descriptor of this type. For further information about this property, see @@#Gender@@

uri: cwrc:hasGenderReported label: has gender (reported) definition: This indicates a person's reported gender. For more information on this property, see @@#Gender@@.

Would be fine? I'll append , which may be self-reported or reported by another. to the necessary properties.

SusanBrown commented 6 years ago

yes, great.

On Apr 24, 2018, at 1:04 PM, Alliyya Mo notifications@github.com wrote:

uri: cwrc:hasGender label: has gender definition: Describes a person's gender, which may be self-reported or reported by another. As with other @@#CulturalForm@@s https://github.com/s, an individual may have more than one property or descriptor of this type. For further information about this property, see @@#Gender@@

uri: cwrc:hasGenderReported label: has gender (reported) definition: This indicates a person's reported gender. For more information on this property, see @@#Gender@@.

Would be fine? I'll append , which may be self-reported or reported by another. to the necessary properties.

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/cwrc/ontology/issues/338#issuecomment-384007614, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAhUoGS9S4dTKcA-vadxlvl4rGdHBeKPks5tr1s4gaJpZM4Te8Ie.

alliyya commented 6 years ago

I remember we discussed cwrc:PoliticalAffiliation being an odd class to have a self-reported predicate, should hasPoliticalAffiliationSelfReported be deprecated? Are there instances where pa's are self-defined?

These are all the predicates that will have has<class>Reported property created.

hasEthnicity hasEthnicitySelfReported

hasGender hasGenderSelfReported

hasGeographicHeritage hasGeographicHeritageSelfReported

hasLinguisticAbility hasLinguisticAbilitySelfReported

hasNationalHeritage hasNationalHeritageSelfReported

hasNationality hasNationalitySelfReported

hasNativeLinguisticAbility hasNativeLinguisticAbilitySelfReported

hasPoliticalAffiliation hasPoliticalAffiliationSelfReported

hasRaceColour hasRaceColourSelfReported

hasReligion hasReligionSelfReported

hasSexuality hasSexualitySelfReported

hasSocialClass hasSocialClassSelfReported

alliyya commented 6 years ago

@lemaka Could you take a look at the Orlando schema and see that these are all appropriate and should have a self-defined attribute. Ex. hasPoliticalAffilation

alliyya commented 6 years ago

French definitions and English definitions should be glanced over and reviewed.

Have all been created in 4fec1cfb5b7fc99577fa35a8b16868d619453057

SusanBrown commented 6 years ago

@jadepncr Would national identity simply be identité nationale?

SusanBrown commented 6 years ago

I've finished reviewing. Done except translation, I think.

alliyya commented 6 years ago

Jade is revising/creating french definitions of all properties in another later issue.