cyanfish / naps2

Scan documents to PDF and more, as simply as possible.
https://www.naps2.com
Other
2.86k stars 327 forks source link

Official Microsoft Store Version? #51

Open AlexanderGH opened 1 year ago

AlexanderGH commented 1 year ago

Unfortunately (though it's WAI with open source), a lot of great open source apps end up being exploited by people to make a quick buck by rebranding them and then selling them. In the more extreme cases, those apps end up being adware, or malware. This is the case for apps like 7zip, and from what I can tell, NAPS, at least based on the screenshot (not going to install it to confirm), ripped straight from your site ttps://www.microsoft.com/store/productId/9PL6FK27J78G (apologies if this app is actually you).

Describe the solution you'd like Similar to the approach paint.net took, provide an official paid version in the microsoft store. It provides more exposure, more users, and also some spare change. It also discourages malicious versions from being uploaded.

Describe alternatives you've considered N/A

Additional context

cyanfish commented 1 year ago

Thanks for bringing that to my attention. I'm planning on providing an official Microsoft Store app with the next non-beta version (and equivalents for Mac/Linux as well), I'm not sure yet if I'll have that be free or paid. I don't think IARC should be an issue.

ohquero commented 1 year ago

Did you known that your app is already present in the Microsoft app store rebranded under the name of "Any Scan"?

2023-07-20_10-38

I'm using NAPS since ever (and I adore your work, saved a ton of headache to me and my family business), so I can recognize it really well. At least it has a score of 4.8, the higher of its category!

alleluia20 commented 3 months ago

@cyanfish: we can now find the NAPS2 app at the Windows store. It is supplied by "Vanced apps". Is it reliable?

On the one hand, they keep the name NAPS2 and they link to the official website for the privacy policy. On the other hand, the app has very few reviews and the supplier looks obscure.

If you think it is reliable, I would install the app from the Windows store, in order to automatically get the updates. But, in doubt, I will continue downloading it from the official website: @cyanfish: do you think we can trust this app?

Thank you, and regards.

cyanfish commented 3 months ago

@alleluia20 It's not official. I have no indication they're doing anything nefarious but there's no guarantee it will keep up to date with the latest NAPS2 version.

kashmirix commented 1 week ago

It's not that the counterfeit app is nefarious at the moment. It's more about its potential to destroy the NAPS2 brand altogether. It's not that such things never happened:

https://github.com/greatsuspender/thegreatsuspender/issues/1263

I'm not a legal expert, but while the NAPS2 code is distributed under GPL, some sort of trademarking the NAPS2 term (as a wordmark) may make sense. Trademarking is expressly permitted by GPL and would offer some recourse in cases of redistribution under the NAPS2 name whenever the developer feels like enforcing it.