cyclosm / cyclosm-cartocss-style

Cycle oriented CartoCSS style.
https://www.cyclosm.org
Other
230 stars 44 forks source link

render access/vehicle=forestry/agricultural same as vehicle=privat and vehicle=no #671

Open road-runner-osm opened 1 month ago

road-runner-osm commented 1 month ago

vehicle/access=forestryand vehicle/access=agricultural are a special case of vehicle/access=private, they only allow certain people to use a track/road. A driving ban (that only allows agricultural or forestry traffic) actually prohibits normal bikes from using a track/street, so imho it should also be rendered in white.

Phyks commented 1 month ago

The reasoning behind this decision is that usually (in practice) access=forestry|agricultural highways are bikable and most taggers may not realize that such access restriction actually prohibits bicycles from using them. See taginfo for instance where only 17% of access=agricultural has a bicycle=yes indication, which seems way too low.

I'm not aware of any tracks that would be dedicated exclusively for agricultural/forestry vehicles and not accessible for pedestrians/bike. The only case I am aware of are actually access=private tracks (which should be tagged as such).

Happy to reconsider if I'm missing something though.