Potential solution

To address the task of evaluating mathematical expressions with respect to variable values provided in a dictionary (varval), we need to modify the compute function. The function should be able to handle variables by replacing them with their corresponding values from the varval dictionary. If the expression is a tuple, it should recursively compute the values of its subexpressions. If the expression is a number, it should return it directly.

How to implement

Here is the step-by-step plan and the corresponding implementation:

Modify the compute function:
- Check if the expression is a variable and if it exists in the varval dictionary. If so, replace it with its value.
- If the expression is a tuple, recursively compute the values of its subexpressions.
- Use the calc function to evaluate the expression once the subexpressions are computed.
- If the expression is a number, return it as is.

Implementation

Here is the modified compute function along with the necessary supporting code:

import math
import random
from numbers import Number

class IllegalOperator(Exception):
    pass

def calc(op, left, right):
    if op == "+":
        return left + right
    elif op == "-":
        return left - right
    elif op == "*":
        return left * right
    elif op == "/":
        return left / right
    else:
        raise IllegalOperator(op)

def compute(e, varval={}):
    if isinstance(e, tuple):
        op, l, r = e
        ll = compute(l, varval)
        rr = compute(r, varval)
        return calc(op, ll, rr)
    elif isinstance(e, str):
        if e in varval:
            return varval[e]
        else:
            raise ValueError(f"Variable '{e}' not found in varval.")
    else:
        return e

def isnumber(e):
    return isinstance(e, Number)

def isvariable(e):
    return isinstance(e, str)

def iscomposite(e):
    return isinstance(e, tuple)

def simplify(e):
    if isinstance(e, tuple):
        op, l, r = e
        ll = simplify(l)
        rr = simplify(r)
        if isnumber(ll) and isnumber(rr):
            return calc(op, ll, rr)
        else:
            return (op, ll, rr)
    else:
        return e

# Example usage
e = ('+', ('-', 'y', 3), ('*', 'x', 4))
print(compute(e, varval={'x': 2}))  # Output should be -1
print(compute(e, varval={'y': 3}))  # Output should be 0
print(compute(e, varval={'x': 2, 'y': 3}))  # Output should be 5

Explanation

The compute function now takes an additional varval dictionary parameter.
If the expression e is a tuple, it recursively computes the values of its subexpressions.
If the expression e is a string (i.e., a variable), it looks up its value in the varval dictionary.
If the expression e is a number, it returns it directly.

This implementation ensures that the compute function can handle expressions involving variables and evaluate them correctly based on the provided variable values.

Click here to create a Pull Request with the proposed solution

Files used for this task:

Changes on math_expression_evaluator.py

To address the issue, we need to modify the `compute` function in the `math_expression_evaluator.py` file to evaluate expressions with respect to variable values provided in the `varval` dictionary. Here is a step-by-step plan and the corresponding implementation: ### Plan 1. **Modify the `compute` function**: - Check if the expression is a variable and if it exists in the `varval` dictionary. If so, replace it with its value. - If the expression is a tuple, recursively compute the values of its subexpressions. - Use the `calc` function to evaluate the expression once the subexpressions are computed. - If the expression is a number, return it as is. ### Implementation Here is the modified `compute` function: ```python import math import random from numbers import Number class IllegalOperator(Exception): pass def calc(op, left, right): if op == "+": return left + right elif op == "-": return left - right elif op == "*": return left * right elif op == "/": return left / right else: raise IllegalOperator(op) def compute(e, varval={}): if isinstance(e, tuple): # We have an expression. op, l, r = e # We compute the subexpressions. ll = compute(l, varval) rr = compute(r, varval) # And on the basis of those, the whole expression. return calc(op, ll, rr) elif isinstance(e, str): # If it's a variable, replace it with its value from varval. if e in varval: return varval[e] else: raise ValueError(f"Variable '{e}' not found in varval.") else: # base expression; just return the number. return e def isnumber(e): return isinstance(e, Number) def isvariable(e): return isinstance(e, str) def iscomposite(e): return isinstance(e, tuple) def simplify(e): if isinstance(e, tuple): op, l, r = e # We simplify the children expressions. ll = simplify(l) rr = simplify(r) # We compute the expression if we can. if isnumber(ll) and isnumber(rr): return calc(op, ll, rr) else: return (op, ll, rr) else: # Leaf. No simplification is possible. return e # Example usage e = ('+', ('-', 'y', 3), ('*', 'x', 4)) print(compute(e, varval={'x': 2})) # Output should be -1 print(compute(e, varval={'y': 3})) # Output should be 0 print(compute(e, varval={'x': 2, 'y': 3})) # Output should be 5 ``` ### Explanation - The `compute` function now takes an additional `varval` dictionary parameter. - If the expression `e` is a tuple, it recursively computes the values of its subexpressions. - If the expression `e` is a string (i.e., a variable), it looks up its value in the `varval` dictionary. - If the expression `e` is a number, it returns it directly. This implementation ensures that the `compute` function can handle expressions involving variables and evaluate them correctly based on the provided variable values.

cyu03245 / Hwk8MathematicalExpressions

Math #1

We have an expression.

We simplify the children expressions.

@title Evaluating an expression with respect to a variable evaluation

YOUR SOLUTION HERE

Potential solution

How to implement

Implementation

Explanation