search

daniellandau / switcher

Gnome Shell extension to switch windows quickly by typing
GNU General Public License v3.0
352 stars 43 forks source link

overlay behaviour #169

Open devvythelopper opened 3 months ago

devvythelopper commented 3 months ago

First of all, the switcher is a great piece of software!

One thing that is unintuitive is, is its overlay behaviour:

  1. I have no way of closing the switcher with the mouse.
  2. I cannot click on some window to activate it, while the switcher is open (but maybe this is after all desirable, because see point 3)
  3. I cannot use my on-screen keyboard while the switcher is open

I realize this is a bit tricky to implement, but to make the switcher usable on my tablet, allowing the on-screen keyboard is a must. And of course there should be a close button, that I can tap on with my touchscreen.

daniellandau commented 3 months ago

Clicking on a row with the mouse activates it and closes the switcher. It used to be that clicking anywhere else closes the switcher, but the way I had implemented it stopped working with a shell release some time ago and I couldn't figure out a new way to make it work.

On-screen keyboard I hadn't even thought about, I'll see what I can do about that.

devvythelopper commented 3 months ago

I tend to open and close the switcher a lot, using the esc key. Because I open it, but then I realize I want to stay with the current app, or using the app switcher and jump back to the last used app is faster. So I think the CANCEL action definitely deserves its gui equivalent (maybe a little x at the right end of the switcher bar).

Maybe you could implement the switcher as a normal window (without decorations of course). And when that window looses focus, this means the user has clicked elsewhere. This would also make keyboard shortcuts work that open the quick settings menu or open apps.

On-screen keyboards tend to be implemented so that they do not make other windows loose focus. And even if the onscreen keyboard makes the window switcher loose focus, you could have a short (and maybe configurable timeout) until you close the switcher window.

devvythelopper commented 3 months ago

And once you have all that you might want to bring your extension to the gnome core developer's attention. Because all this is something that deserves integrating in the core shell ;-)