search

danny0838 / webscrapbook

A browser extension that captures web pages to local device or backend server for future retrieval, organization, annotation, and edit. This project inherits from legacy Firefox add-on ScrapBook X.
Mozilla Public License 2.0
894 stars 119 forks source link

Manifest V3 Support #377

Open grematt opened 6 months ago

grematt commented 6 months ago

Are there plans to migrate the extension to manifest v3 this year?

danny0838 commented 6 months ago

We'll do that as late as possible. In short: MV3 sucks.

Migrating to MV3 gains nothing while has lots of compatibility issues to deal with, some of which are even impossible or is extremely annoying for the end user, unless Google and Mozilla improve the API. It also elevates the requirement and makes it impossible for older browser users to use it.

abdd22 commented 1 week ago

嘛，我就以中文发言了。

Brave表示他们仍然支持MV2，https://brave.com/blog/brave-shields-manifest-v3/

vivaldi表示跟进chrome（基本没救了）Edge仍然不清楚（证据是Tampermonkey仍然不是5.3.0版本，也就是MV3的版本）

总之很麻烦...（一开始Tampermonkey和UBO都不支持MV3）