search

dashhive / DashTx.js

Create TX hex for payments and such
MIT License
3 stars 0 forks source link

ref: default to ALL + ANYONECANPAY #67

Closed coolaj86 closed 4 months ago

coolaj86 commented 4 months ago

Although legacy software typically sends ALL, ALL+ANYONECANPAY is "required" for Coin Join, and more importantly, it doesn't leak unnecessary information about the transaction characteristics.

Namely, it doesn't dictate that the transaction must have been a single-wallet transaction. Since multi-wallet transactions are supported, and single wallets can sign the same way a multi-wallet process would, there doesn't seem to be any reason to leak that characteristic information.

Possible Negative Consequence: If a generous party decides to pick up your tab and pay the bills for you, and you were looking specifically at the txid rather than the addresses, you might be expecting one transaction id, but instead see another.

riongull commented 4 months ago

Let's discuss this. I want to make sure I understand the decision and tradeoff here.