data-science-hub / data-science-hub.github.io

Website
4 stars 2 forks source link

Which criteria apply to which type of paper #17

Closed tkuhn closed 7 years ago

tkuhn commented 7 years ago

We need to define which of the reviewing criteria apply to which type of paper: http://datasciencehub.net/guidelines.html

Position papers and surveys need to be evaluated differently. And invited vision papers should probably be a category on their own.

micheldumontier commented 7 years ago

Invited vision papers are position papers. the main criteria are sound argumentation that is evidenced by literature. no new methods or findings required.

tkuhn commented 7 years ago

The review criteria are now formulated in a way that applies to all types of papers (except reports, which we will include later on). See issue #24.