Closed codycooperross closed 10 months ago
kjgarza
commented
2 years ago oops, I think this was kind of left behind. check this out: https://github.com/datacite/volpino/issues/99
I think I forgot to merge that PR https://github.com/datacite/volpino/pull/100
MaryHirsch
commented
2 years ago another user has reported a similar issue. some dois have conference paper resourceTypeGeneral https://profiles.datacite.org/admin/claims?user_id=0000-0002-0036-319x
codycooperross
commented
2 years ago another user has reported a similar issue. some dois have conference paper resourceTypeGeneral https://profiles.datacite.org/admin/claims?user_id=0000-0002-0036-319x
This was a separate issue that has now been resolved #115
Describe the bug
Some manual ORCID DOI claims remain in a "waiting" state indefinitely and receive errors like the following:
[Error] 0000-0002-4684-9769 – 10.4126/38m-002645284: [{"status"=>400, "title"=>{"response_code"=>"400", "developer_message"=>"400 Bad request: invalid value 'dissertation' for enum 'org.orcid.jaxb.model.common.WorkType'", "user_message"=>"Invalid value for type. ", "error_code"=>"9051", "more_info"=>"https://members.orcid.org/api/resources/troubleshooting"}}]The claimed DOIs do not appear in ORCID accounts.
Expected Behaviour
The claim should be processed appropriately and transition from "waiting" to "done".
Steps to Reproduce
Attempt to claim a DOI like the following using the "Claim DOI" button: https://commons.datacite.org/doi.org/10.13140/rg.2.1.2522.5849 https://commons.datacite.org/doi.org/10.4126/38m-38m-000000463
Context (Environment)
The issue affects manual ORCID claiming in Commons.
Proposal
Hypothesis
This issue seems to only affect DOIs with a specific resourceType, specifically those listed here in the orcid_client gem here:
https://github.com/datacite/orcid_client/blob/9d5237e3e4369c0decf440bbe11575c73ae0bde3/lib/orcid_client/work_type.rb#L42
This is likely because the assigned ORCID work type, "dissertation", does not exist in the ORCID data model. Rather, the model includes work type "dissertation-thesis":
https://github.com/ORCID/orcid-model/blob/a612165fee82fdbf930a381fb09b8f30e14340f6/src/main/java/org/orcid/jaxb/model/common/WorkType.java#L18
Possible Implementation
Changing the assigned work type in orcid_client from "dissertation" to "dissertation-thesis" may resolve this issue. The orcid_client work_type.rb code is also mirrored in the Typeable concern in volpino, but it's unclear if changing the code here would be significant:
https://github.com/datacite/volpino/blob/d325a404586efa1d1529af9549652301292fe309/app/models/concerns/typeable.rb#L20