Unable to work at all

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

Hello,

Thank you very much for your work, I can't wait to be able to use it.

My issue in a few words

• I start restreamer from the docker container,
• I go to localhost:8080
• and when I try and stream to YouTube, it just simply won't work at all.

Details about the test I ran

I run restreamer as a docker-compose :

version: '3.7'

# Settings and configurations that are common for all containers
x-restream-common: &restream-common
  image: datarhei/restreamer:0.6.8
  # command: server --console-address ":9001" http://minio{1...4}/data{1...2}
  expose:
    - "8080"
    # I ran a netstat -tulpn intocontainers to
    # check which network ports were used, and
    # tested exposing those
    # ---> it just does not hel at all to expose those, it's
    #      just spaghetti networking inside the container, between
    #      the software components and throguh container internal NGINX 

    # - "3000"
    # - "1935"
  ports:
    - "8080:8080"
    # I ran a netstat -tulpn intocontainers to
    # check which network ports were used, and
    # tested exposing those
    # ---> it just does not hel at all to expose those, it's
    #      just spaghetti networking inside the container, between
    #      the software components and throguh container internal NGINX 

    # - "3000:3000"
    # - "1935:1935"
  restart: always
  environment:
    RS_USERNAME: $RS_USERNAME
    RS_PASSWORD: $RS_PASSWORD
    RS_DEBUG: true
  # healthcheck:
    # test: ["CMD", "curl", "-f", "http://localhost:8080/"]
    # interval: 30s
    # timeout: 20s
    # retries: 3

services:
  restreamer:
    <<: *restream-common
    # hostname: restreamer.pokus.io
    volumes:
      - restreamer_data1-1:/restreamer/db

## This config uses default local driver,
## For custom volumes replace with volume driver configuration.
volumes:
  restreamer_data1-1:
    driver: local

• I use the url rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s (I fill in both the web page at http://localhost:8080 ), I get :

• In Webui an error message in a red striped box, stating :

"Your stream wasn't accessible. rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted "

• The following error logs :

connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s" in 6000ms
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:42.828] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s"
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:42.828] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:42.840] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:42.842] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s" in 6000ms
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:48.809] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s"
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:48.809] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:48.821] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:48.823] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s" in 6000ms
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:54.831] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s"
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:54.832] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:54.844] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:54.847] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s" in 6000ms
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:03:56.419] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Stop streaming
restream-restreamer-1  | [09-12-2021 06:04:00.853] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s"

• Note I am puzzled because i do not get any difference in the logs whether i set RS_DEBUG to true or not. (solved, see https://github.com/datarhei/restreamer/blob/2d851cdbadb1d7f2c4ffed7750c08daf43ea709f/docker-compose.yml#L16 )
• Yes ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s is a secret, and I rotated it (it won't work if you try using that secret)

My only guess as of today : RTMP is a 2 way TCP connection, so i need a public IP, Am I Right ? If so, i think it woud be worth mentioning it somewhere, like in the install instructions and/or the YouTube howtos.

I so hope I will have help from anyone, there are people who created issues 15 days ago who state they can successfully stream to YouTube (so i guess I have just a basic error somewhere... So frustrating..)

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

I gave it another try, with the provided docker-compose

And I get the exact same error, only this time i do get DEBUG level logs :

• the docker-compose :

version: "3"
services:
  restreamer:
    image: datarhei/restreamer
    container_name: restreamer
    ports:
      - 1935:1935
      - 8080:8080
    networks:
      - frontend
    volumes:
      - "~/db:/restreamer/db"
    environment:
      - RS_USERNAME=admin
      - RS_PASSWORD=datarhei
      - RS_LOGLEVEL=4
      - RS_TIMEZONE=Europe/Berlin
      - RS_SNAPSHOT_INTERVAL=1m
    # deploy:
      # replicas: 1
      # restart_policy:
        # condition: any
        # delay: 5s
        # window: 10s

  fblive:
    image: dweomer/stunnel
    container_name: fblive
    expose:
      - 1935
    networks:
      - frontend
    restart: always
    environment:
      - STUNNEL_SERVICE=fb-live
      - STUNNEL_CLIENT=yes
      - STUNNEL_ACCEPT=1935
      - STUNNEL_CONNECT=live-api-s.facebook.com:443
      - STUNNEL_VERIFY_CHAIN=NO

  https-portal:
    image: steveltn/https-portal:1
    container_name: https-portal
    ports:
      - 80:80
      - 443:443
    restart: always
    networks:
      - frontend
    environment:
      DOMAINS: localhost -> http://restreamer:8080
      STAGE: local
      # DOMAINS: yourdomain.com -> http://restreamer:8080
      # STAGE: production

networks:
  frontend:

• The debug logs i get :

fblive  | Generating a RSA private key
fblive  | ...............+++++
fblive  | .....................................................................+++++
fblive  | writing new private key to '/etc/stunnel/stunnel.key'
fblive  | -----
fblive  | Cannot write random bytes:
fblive  | 140617675774792:error:2407007A:random number generator:RAND_write_file:Not a regular file:crypto/rand/randfile.c:183:Filename=/dev/urandom
fblive  | '/etc/ssl/certs/ca-certificates.crt' -> '/usr/local/share/ca-certificates/stunnel-ca.crt'
fblive  | '/etc/stunnel/stunnel.pem' -> '/usr/local/share/ca-certificates/stunnel.crt'
fblive  | WARNING: ca-certificates.crt does not contain exactly one certificate or CRL: skipping
fblive  | WARNING: ca-cert-stunnel-ca.pem does not contain exactly one certificate or CRL: skipping
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: Initializing inetd mode configuration
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Clients allowed=512000
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG5[ui]: stunnel 5.59 on x86_64-alpine-linux-musl platform
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG5[ui]: Compiled/running with OpenSSL 1.1.1k  25 Mar 2021
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG5[ui]: Threading:PTHREAD Sockets:POLL,IPv6 TLS:ENGINE,OCSP,PSK,SNI
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: errno: (*__errno_location())
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: Initializing inetd mode configuration
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG5[ui]: Reading configuration from file /etc/stunnel/stunnel.conf
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG5[ui]: UTF-8 byte order mark not detected
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: No PRNG seeding was required
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: Initializing service [fb-live]
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: stunnel default security level set: 2
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Ciphers: HIGH:!aNULL:!SSLv2:!DH:!kDHEPSK
fblive  | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: TLSv1.3 ciphersuites: TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384:TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256:TLS_CHACHA20_POLY1305_SHA256
restreamer  |
restreamer  | > Restreamer@0.6.8 start /restreamer
restreamer  | > node ./src/start
restreamer  |
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.846] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] Init webserver with PROD environment
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.896] [INFO ]      _       _             _           _
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.897] [INFO ]   __| | __ _| |_ __ _ _ __| |___   ___(_)
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.897] [INFO ]  / _  |/ _  | __/ _  |  __|  _  |/  _ | |
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.897] [INFO ] | (_| | (_| | || (_| | |  | | | |  __/| |
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.897] [INFO ] |_____|_____|_||_____|_|  |_| |_|____||_|
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.897] [INFO ]
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.898] [INFO ] Restreamer v0.6.8
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.898] [INFO ]
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: TLS options: 0x02100004 (+0x00000000, -0x00000000)
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: Loading certificate from file: /etc/stunnel/stunnel.pem
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: Certificate loaded from file: /etc/stunnel/stunnel.pem
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: Loading private key from file: /etc/stunnel/stunnel.key
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: Private key loaded from file: /etc/stunnel/stunnel.key
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Private key check succeeded
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG4[ui]: Service [fb-live] needs authentication to prevent MITM attacks
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: DH initialization skipped: client section
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.898] [INFO ] ENVIRONMENTS
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.898] [INFO ] More information in our Docs
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.898] [INFO ]
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.898] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_NODEJS_PORT = 3000 (using default) - Webserver port of application.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.898] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_NODEJS_ENV = prod (using default) - Node.js Environment ('dev' or 'prod').
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.899] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_LOGLEVEL = 4 - Logging level (0=no logging, 1=ERROR, 2=WARN, 3=INFO, 4=DEBUG).
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.899] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_TIMEZONE = Europe/Berlin - Set the timezone. Accepts Olson timezone IDs.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.899] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_SNAPSHOT_INTERVAL = 1m - Interval for new snapshots (in milliseconds, use suffix 's' for seconds, 'm' for minutes). Use a value of 0 to disable snapshots.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.899] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_USERNAME = admin - Username for the backend.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.899] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_PASSWORD = ****** - Password for the backend.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.899] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_TOKEN =  (using default) - Token for pushing an RTMP stream.
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: ECDH initialization
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: ECDH initialized with curves X25519:P-256:X448:P-521:P-384
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG5[ui]: Configuration successful
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Deallocating deployed section defaults
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.899] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_DEBUG_HEAPDUMPS = false (using default) - Create heapdumps of application.
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Binding service [fb-live]
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Listening file descriptor created (FD=9)
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Setting accept socket options (FD=9)
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Option SO_REUSEADDR set on accept socket
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[ui]: Service [fb-live] (FD=9) bound to 0.0.0.0:1935
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[ui]: Created pid file /var/run/stunnel/stunnel.pid
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[cron]: Cron thread initialized
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[cron]: Executing cron jobs
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG6[cron]: Cron jobs completed in 0 seconds
fblive      | 2021.12.09 05:55:43 LOG7[cron]: Waiting 86400 seconds
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.899] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_DEBUG = false (using default) - Enables debug reporting.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.900] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_AUDIO = auto (using default) - Audio track handling: auto, none (remove audio), silence (force silence), aac (force AAC), mp3 (force MP3).
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.900] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_HTTPS = false (using default) - Enables HTTPS support for admin interface and embeddable player.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.900] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_INPUTSTREAM =  (using default) - Automatically start pulling from this stream on a fresh Restreamer installation.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.900] [INFO ] [                   ENV] RS_OUTPUTSTREAM =  (using default) - Automatically start pushing to this stream on a fresh Restreamer installation.
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:48.900] [INFO ] [                 NGINX] Starting ...
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.183] [INFO ] [                 NGINX] Successfully started
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.184] [INFO ] [        RestreamerData] Checking jsondb file...
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.188] [DEBUG] [        RestreamerData] Error reading "v1.db": Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/restreamer/db/v1.json'
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.194] [DEBUG] [       checkForUpdates] Checking for updates...
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.203] [INFO ] [              publicIP] Retrieving public IP ...
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.207] [INFO ] [             Webserver] Starting ...
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.239] [INFO ] [             Webserver] Running on port 3000
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.244] [DEBUG] [    repeatToLocalNginx] Update state from "stopped" to "disconnected"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.249] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "stopped" to "disconnected"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.253] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.253] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.300] [INFO ] [              publicIP] Found public IP: 92.184.102.196
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.502] [INFO ] [       checkForUpdates] Update checking succeeded. No updates available
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.503] [DEBUG] [       checkForUpdates] local: 0.6.8; remote: 0.6.8
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:55:49.503] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting update
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:25.893] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/" 200 13ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 -
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:25.895] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/" 200 15ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 -
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:26.088] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/authenticated" 200 3ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 5
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:26.088] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/authenticated" 200 3ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 5
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:26.118] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/v1/version" 200 1ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 47
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:26.119] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/v1/version" 200 2ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 47
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:52.269] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] POST "/login" 200 1ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 42
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:52.270] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] POST "/login" 200 2ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 42
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:52.371] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Got "checkStates" event
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:56:52.371] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:26.132] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/" 200 1ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 -
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:26.133] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/" 200 2ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 -
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:26.414] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/authenticated" 200 1ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 4
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:26.415] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/authenticated" 200 2ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 4
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:26.453] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/v1/version" 200 1ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 47
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:26.454] [DEBUG] [             Webserver] GET "/v1/version" 200 2ms ::ffff:127.0.0.1 47
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:26.521] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Got "checkStates" event
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:26.521] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.624] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Got "startStream" event
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.624] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Set user action from "stop" to "start"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.634] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.634] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "disconnected" to "connecting"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.639] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.640] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.640] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.644] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.645] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.646] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.650] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.652] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.652] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.657] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:48.658] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.659] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.660] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.660] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.664] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.665] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.665] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.669] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.673] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.674] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.674] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.679] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:58:54.679] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.680] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.681] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.681] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.686] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.687] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.687] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.690] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.695] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.696] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.697] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.701] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:00.701] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.701] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.702] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.702] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.707] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.707] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.707] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.711] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.715] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.717] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.717] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.722] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:06.722] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.688] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.688] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.688] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.693] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.694] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.694] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.699] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.704] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.705] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.705] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.710] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:12.710] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.710] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.711] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.711] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.715] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.715] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.715] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.719] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.723] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.725] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.725] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.730] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:18.730] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.732] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.733] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.733] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.738] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.740] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.740] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.744] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.749] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.751] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.751] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.755] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:24.756] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.759] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.760] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.760] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.765] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.766] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.766] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.770] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.774] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.775] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer  | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.776] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
https-portal  | [s6-init] making user provided files available at /var/run/s6/etc...exited 0.
https-portal  | [s6-init] ensuring user provided files have correct perms...exited 0.
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.780] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:30.781] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.782] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.783] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
https-portal  | [fix-attrs.d] applying ownership & permissions fixes...
https-portal  | [fix-attrs.d] done.
https-portal  | [cont-init.d] executing container initialization scripts...
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.783] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.788] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.788] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.788] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.792] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
https-portal  | [cont-init.d] 00-welcome: executing...
https-portal  |
https-portal  | ========================================
https-portal  | HTTPS-PORTAL v1.21.0
https-portal  | ========================================
https-portal  |
https-portal  | [cont-init.d] 00-welcome: exited 0.
https-portal  | [cont-init.d] 20-setup: executing...
https-portal  | DH parameters appear to be ok.
https-portal  | -----BEGIN DH PARAMETERS-----
https-portal  | MIIBCAKCAQEAjK4ROj8gmx3dy7E/1kdjG51iNV6SQYLQrwJJo/SqRICGsBcKNMUX
https-portal  | onQe3qdu8nciB+CyCj1F0U5lQJq6ID3w5/WKXyqQS7vZZF/gyEeNlm6zFgRSGs6K
https-portal  | Nas0dEcZg5TBQAPWv62gmO+rdMaAcExGOZYpbqLGfeztBiaLPq12EUW2YlX1sVFB
https-portal  | Elqc9OGqKBzEKcGDtxIaz9IWz28gnoqYD6yxy32HKQVv8oDvBL+2e3n3AMyce6u3
https-portal  | KA09PuNMGcFPljab/bXDTI1WPz2nYH8fx50Km8rq3C0wEMAqQbCKUBVpm2dRlp4Q
https-portal  | HgXGxxvsBr9gr10GYVeFYR207Qm8RuB4AwIBAg==
https-portal  | -----END DH PARAMETERS-----
https-portal  | RSA key ok
https-portal  | Generating RSA private key, 2048 bit long modulus (2 primes)
https-portal  | ......................+++++
https-portal  | ...................................................+++++
https-portal  | e is 65537 (0x010001)
https-portal  | Self-signing test certificate for localhost
https-portal  | Generating a RSA private key
https-portal  | ..........+++++
https-portal  | ......................................................................+++++
https-portal  | writing new private key to '/var/lib/https-portal/localhost/local/domain.ongoing.key'
https-portal  | -----
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.796] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.797] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
https-portal  | Signed certificate for localhost
https-portal  | [cont-init.d] 20-setup: exited 0.
https-portal  | [cont-init.d] 30-set-docker-gen-status: executing...
https-portal  | [cont-init.d] 30-set-docker-gen-status: exited 0.
https-portal  | [cont-init.d] done.
https-portal  | [services.d] starting services
https-portal  | [services.d] done.
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.797] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.802] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:36.802] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.771] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.771] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.771] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.779] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.780] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.780] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.783] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.788] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.789] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.790] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.795] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:42.796] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.798] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.798] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.798] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.804] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.804] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.804] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.809] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.814] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.815] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.816] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.821] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:48.822] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.827] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.827] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.827] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.835] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.835] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.836] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.839] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.844] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.845] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.845] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.853] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 06:59:54.853] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.853] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.853] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.853] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.858] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.859] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.859] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.862] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.867] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.868] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.868] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.872] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:00.873] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.875] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.875] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.875] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.880] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.880] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.880] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.884] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.890] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.891] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.891] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.896] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:06.897] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.867] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.869] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.870] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.875] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.875] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.875] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.879] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.883] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.884] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.885] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.889] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:12.889] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.893] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.893] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.893] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.898] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.898] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.899] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.902] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.907] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.908] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.908] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.913] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:18.913] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.914] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.914] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.914] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.919] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.919] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.919] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.925] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.932] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.933] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.933] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.939] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:24.939] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.942] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.942] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.942] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.947] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.947] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.948] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.951] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.956] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.957] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.958] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.962] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:30.963] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.965] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.965] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.965] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.971] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.971] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.971] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.975] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.979] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.981] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.981] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.986] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:36.986] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.952] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.953] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.953] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.958] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.959] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.959] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.963] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.969] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.970] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.970] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.975] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:42.975] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.978] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.978] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.978] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.983] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.984] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.985] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.989] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.994] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.995] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:48.995] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:49.000] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:49.000] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.000] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.001] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.001] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.006] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.007] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.007] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.010] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.015] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.016] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.016] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.021] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:00:55.021] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.023] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.023] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Start streaming
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.024] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "error" to "connecting"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.029] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: global
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.029] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: video
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.029] [DEBUG] [            Restreamer] Adding option: rtmp
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.033] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.037] [ERROR] [                 NGINX] :1935
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.039] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Failed to spawn ffmpeg: rtmp://localhost:1935/hls/live.stream: Operation not permitted
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.039] [DEBUG] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Update state from "connecting" to "error"
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.044] [INFO ] [repeatToOptionalOutput] Retry to connect to "rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/x4b8-2pvj-1kd6-b85d-7xse" in 6000ms
restreamer    | [09-12-2021 07:01:01.044] [DEBUG] [          WSController] Emitting updateStreamData

[civita]

I use the url rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s (I fill in both the web page at http://localhost:8080 )

Hi @Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle, did you mean that you put the same url in both source and external streaming-server? If you want to stream something to YouTube, the url in source should be like local rtsp:// from ipcam or external RTMP/RTSP/HLS links.

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

HI @civita ,

• In the Web UI at http://localhost:8080 :
  • I have two fields that i can film in : that, because I checked the checkbox "external streaming server" (as i read in docs)
  • I tried both :
  • fill in both fields with rtmp://a.rtmp.youtube.com/live2/ue03-gu47-v24y-xxjh-3c5s
  • fill in only one filed (the one for external streaming service)
  • in both case, same error, that i described in my issue
  • I do not understand what you explain me about rtsp : both youtube and restreamer docs state that if i wanna stream to YouTube, URLs to use are starting with rtmp://, see your youtube account and https://datarhei.github.io/restreamer/docs/guides-youtube.html#push-to-youtube

Note: just to be sue it is clear, i run restreamer serer on my machine at home, behind my ISP Router, that's why http://localhost:8080 .

If we should not run restreamer from home, then I assume that all raspberry pi use cases imply also getting a public IP / working with DynDNS, or a reverse tunnel

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

@civita thank you for your first message, i hope we can solve that : I wanted to add i just ran the test again, with exact same conditions than i described, and i get exact same error.

Note that i sincerely want it to work, many people are asking me for this tool, and are waiting for my definitive answer (will we be able to use this tool, with serious community).

RTSP

About RTSP, i run restraeamer from my personal PC, which has an integrated Webcam. It shpuld be considered a network camera ..? I am puzzled there, and the YouTube documentation page does not mention anything about RTSP

[Tokolosh]

You need a different source. You cant pull and send to the same address. RTMP/RTSP/HLS Video Source is intended for your IPCam or other Device/OBS Stream

External Streaming-Server is where you can enter the Youtube URL

[civita]

About RTSP, i run restraeamer from my personal PC, which has an integrated Webcam.

Hi @Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle , suppose that your scenario is streaming the webcam from local to YouTube, then in the "source" field should be something related to the webcam. This divides into two possible conditions:

1. Your webcam is on your pc/mac and restreamer is running somewhere else (e.g., raspberry pi/other linux machine)
2. Your webcam and restreamer is running in the same machine

Based on the your previous comment, I supposed that you are in the second condition, then if you are running linux machine and use a Video4Linux-compatible webcam (you can check if there is device in /dev/video0), the steps is in here.

If you are running windows machine / unsupported webcam, I think you can just start a YouTube live with browser.

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

Thanks so much @Tokolosh @civita very sad, that this explanation that you give, is not there in the docs, at https://datarhei.github.io/restreamer/docs/guides-youtube.html .

I think i will make gift at some point, to improve docs.

After reading what you explained, I think best natural setup is :

• to install OBS on my PC : indeed i just checked that OBS catches my PC's integrated webcam
• to run OBS on same machine with additional 1935 port and RS_TOKEN in docker-compose
• note that in my case, if i want to use restreamer instead of just YouTube and web browser (of cousre this will work):
  • that's because i want to stream from my PC, to multiple platforms.
  • and because oi want to test locally before terraforming the restreamer server to the cloud

Thanks a lot guys again, i will try that and feed results back

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

Ok, I just tried using the OBS setup, I followed https://datarhei.github.io/restreamer/docs/guides-obs.html .

Following those instructions exactly as they state, It still does not work at all.Very unclear anyway.

We really lack :

• one tutorial, you just follow it and it works.
• I think the use case where you want to live stream to multiple platforms, from your home PC is a very common one, if not the one use case (not acceptable that we don't have that)
• I am devops, and if I can't do that straight off, imagine other people...
• I will need time to sort it all out, and I will feed back for community, with nice documentation, and YouTube videos...
• Thanks a lot guys for your tips.

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

@Tokolosh example given :

• So If I set both source and external streaming server,
• then I have to click on 2 "start" buttons ?
• one example of one very unclear thing.
• really too bad there is no demo on YouTube

[civita]

@Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle

Hi, What's your setup please? like which OS do you use, scenario, etc. I don't think this is difficult to work on, and if you like I can provide demo for you.

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

@Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle

Hi, What's your setup please? like which OS do you use, scenario, etc. I don't think this is difficult to work on, and if you like I can provide demo for you.

Thank you so much @civita !, that would be awesome !

hello @civita , Here is my setup :

• on a macbook pro, I have the integrated webcam, and on that same machine :
  • I run the docker-compose
  • I have installed Streamlabs OBS (using brew.sh )
  • I want the user of that mac book pro, to be then able to live stream to multiple platforms, from his mac book pro : YouTube, and any other one (twitch, facebook, whatever...)

my docker-compose :

version: "3"
services:
  restreamer:
    image: datarhei/restreamer
    container_name: restreamer
    ports:
      - 1935:1935
      - 8080:8080
    networks:
      - frontend
    volumes:
      - "~/db:/restreamer/db"
    environment:
      - RS_USERNAME=admin
      - RS_PASSWORD=datarhei
      - RS_LOGLEVEL=4
      - RS_TIMEZONE=Europe/Berlin
      - RS_SNAPSHOT_INTERVAL=1m
      -  RS_TOKEN=unsecuretoken
    # deploy:
      # replicas: 1
      # restart_policy:
        # condition: any
        # delay: 5s
        # window: 10s

  fblive:
    image: dweomer/stunnel
    container_name: fblive
    expose:
      - 1935
    networks:
      - frontend
    restart: always
    environment:
      - STUNNEL_SERVICE=fb-live
      - STUNNEL_CLIENT=yes
      - STUNNEL_ACCEPT=1935
      - STUNNEL_CONNECT=live-api-s.facebook.com:443
      - STUNNEL_VERIFY_CHAIN=NO

  https-portal:
    image: steveltn/https-portal:1
    container_name: https-portal
    ports:
      - 80:80
      - 443:443
    restart: always
    networks:
      - frontend
    environment:
      DOMAINS: localhost -> http://restreamer:8080
      STAGE: local
      # DOMAINS: yourdomain.com -> http://restreamer:8080
      # STAGE: production

networks:
  frontend:

I would really like to find something really useful I can contribute to thank the restreamer community, so supportive ! Are there things about devops / CICD / or documentation website which would be apprreciated / useful ? Don't hesitate saying if any idea, I'll find something i think eventually.

[matigumma]

Hi there check this: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/3006768?hl=en&ref_topic=9257985

i think its not permitted to push empty frames, or incorrect configuration

[civita]

on a macbook pro, I have the integrated webcam, and on that same machine :

• I run the docker-compose
• I have installed Streamlabs OBS (using brew.sh )
• I want the user of that mac book pro, to be then able to live stream to multiple platforms, from his mac book pro : YouTube, and any other one (twitch, facebook, whatever...)

Hi @Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle ,

Thanks for the clarification. If I understand correctly, you would like to stream macbook internal webcam to multiple platforms (yt, twitch, etc.), then you might look at this guide and obs setup

For the obs setup, in stream:

Server: rtmp://localhost/live
Stream Key: external.stream?token=something_secret

in output tab, choose "x264" in encoder.

For restreamer, you may have to create multiple docker instances, in order to stream to multiple platforms.

docker run -d --restart always \
     --name restreamer \
     -e "RS_USERNAME=admin" -e "RS_PASSWORD=datarhei" \
     -e "RS_TOKEN=something_secret" -p 1935:1935 \
     -p 8080:8080 -v -v ${HOME}/restreamer/db:/restreamer/db \
     datarhei/restreamer:latest

If you run multiple docker images, remember to rename instance and remove -p 1935:1935 (for the rest of instances) and change volume mapping.

In restreamer webui, in source: rtmp://localhost/live/external.stream?token=something_secret, and in External Streaming-Server type your yt/twitch url. Finally, press start in both obs and restreamer:

By the way, there are obs plugins which enable multi-rtmp you might be interested in.

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

HI @civita thank you so much for this new answer from you, and I also want to say thank you so much to all of other community members answering here, it is so supportive.

@civita you indeed perfectly described and understood what i was trying to do on my mac book.

I will give you further informations on my work with restreamer, i want to give a hint on what my long run goal is :

• I am sure you all know streamyard or https://restream.io
• There today exists zero open source project, where you run terraform, and you end up witrh something similar to https://restream.io . And this makes all citizens dependent on what a few private companies may be doomed to do, (i let your imagination play here).
• I value your community's work, because it's active, and it is very important to citizens : without this, they cannot be free to broadcast to other fellow citizens, and their communications across the internet are doomed to censorship.

And since the community is so awesome, I decide now i will work on making what is necessary :

• so that you run terraform, and you end up with something similar to https://restream.io
• this means there are very important features that are required :
  • auto scaling :
  • we need a helm chart, (I am sure it wil need at least a few PRs),
  • and after that we need a kubernetes operator. I will focus on those 3 features . This will certainly make me work on Restream 's CICD
  • the terraform must work against at least 3 cloud providers from USA, China, and Russia (all 3 mandatory), and last but most important of all : the terraform must work against a 100% open source cloud provider like OpenStack. Kubernetes, the CNI and CSI plugins must be built from source. I think of another Cloud provider I am working on, which will allow to launch a kubernetes cluster on fleet of mobile phones, all wifi connected to 4G/5G router.
  • multi-tenancy : that i will be interested, but i think important that the auto scaling feature comes first. restreamer needs to get "Kubernetes Native", before a major feature, like multi tenancy. Plus I think if we have a one tenant only SAAS platform, it will just as well make the citizen free (on worst case each citizen will run its own one tenant only). Never the less, we will need multi tenancy at some point, for example for the citiznes to share price of paying the infrastructure below there (the AWS or alibaba.com cloud bill).

So ok, plan :

• first finish testing a setup up to use restreamer from my laptop just like described by @civita
• then i will respawn the entire cicd : that will begin by git cloning all https://github.com/datarhei/restreamer repository, into a new github org of mine.
• then i will finish work on CICD, by creating a new Circle CI Orb (and the equivalent of an Orb in Drone CI), that will automate helm chart deployment
• this is where i will start work on Helm Chart

Thank you so much all for your support, all your mesages, and all the work done until today!

[svenerbeck]

Thank you very much for your comment. We have implemented the function in the Restreamer v2 🚀 Have fun with it.

[Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle]

• PRs

Thank you for your answer! I will test v2 as soon as possible, to try the new features (multi tnenancy , helm chart with auto scalability ...), I ll give some feed back asap!

[jstabenow]

Hey @Jean-Baptiste-Lasselle Your ideas sound very interesting and if you need help, get in touch.

BTW: Have a look at our backend: https://github.com/datarhei/core

With that, a lot should already be possible.