datasets / un-locode

United Nations Codes for Trade and Transport Locations (UN/LOCODE) and Country Codes
https://datahub.io/core/un-locode
146 stars 56 forks source link

Minor fixes #30

Closed gradedSystem closed 1 month ago

gradedSystem commented 1 month ago

Changes made:

cc @anuveyatsu

sabas commented 1 month ago

Hi, can I review the changes tomorrow? Thanks

gradedSystem commented 1 month ago

sure you can review @sabas

cristan commented 1 month ago

I'll be the bearer of bad news: I don't think there's any chance this will be merged.

The thing is: this project isn't the actual source of the UN/LOCODE dataset: it's only a way to take the official distribution and package it in a much more convenient way. Maybe this can be made a little bit clearer in the README.

Your changes both change the form of the data (the ordering of the countries for example), as well as its contents. The form could be changed as part of this project, but any content has to go though a committee at UNECE. sabas is in contact with them though, so he might be able to make some of these a reality.

Anyway, let's look at your changes:

I'm sorry for the effort you put into this, but I don't see these changes ending up in this repo like this at all.

anuveyatsu commented 1 month ago

hi @cristan thank you for pointing this out! Please note that there is another pull request here with changes to the python code #29 - could you please take a look at it and leave your comments there? I believe that the changes in the data content is a result of those python scripts, i.e., if a country name has changed it must be an issue in the upstream. However, we need to confirm it first. cc @gradedSystem

gradedSystem commented 1 month ago

@sabas @cristan @anuveyatsu going to close this pull request going to look into fixing the code with suggested changes