search

dave0 / leaguerunner

Leaguerunner is a web-based application for managing scheduling, score submission and standings for an Ultimate Frisbee league.
GNU General Public License v2.0
15 stars 4 forks source link

Ties in standings glitch? #78

Open psychoned opened 11 years ago

psychoned commented 11 years ago

Just wondering if there is a glitch in the way ratings ties are listed in the rankings... twice this year our team has been tied in rankings points with a team and have been ranked below them despite having more wins, more points for, fewer points against and a better +/-, not to mention having beaten them in a head to head game. It matters not for general week to week standings, but when it comes to splitting the ladder into playoff pools it could have an effect.

Cheers, Ken

dave0 commented 11 years ago

Nope, it's not a glitch. For ladder leagues, the ranking criteria are, as chosen by OCUA:

For non-ladder leagues, the criteria are:

I've forgotten the historical reason for those tiebreaker values, but checking the git history it looks like it's been that way since summer 2007.

Unfortunately, the "Summer League Handbook" page that contained the tiebreaker info on ocua.ca seems to have been nuked in the last site redesign. I'll leave this ticket open and document the tiebreaker criteria within Leaguerunner as a popup help item when I get time, so it can't accidentally be deleted by wayward web designers.

psychoned commented 11 years ago

Well, thanks for the clarification, Dave. I think it would be good to add the tiebreaker documentation, but certainly no rush on that.

Also, I was thinking the other day that it might be nice to add a "Nickname" field to the account, that people could fill in if they desired, and would show up on roster lists and such in quotations if it was populated, such as Paul "PMo" Morrison, or Steve "Wheels" Penny.... There are a number of people in the league that eventually develop a nickname that sticks, and invariably newer people just hear their nickname and never hear their real name. So this would add some clarity.

Again, just an idea, and no hurry... but thought I'd mention it.

Hope all is well, Ken

On Wed, Jul 10, 2013 at 5:15 AM, dave0 notifications@github.com wrote:

Nope, it's not a glitch. For ladder leagues, the ranking criteria are, as chosen by OCUA:

  • Rating
  • SOTG
  • wins
  • +/-
  • points for

Unfortunately, the "Summer League Handbook" page that contained this info on ocua.ca seems to have been nuked in the last site redesign. I'll leave this ticket open and document the tiebreaker criteria within Leaguerunner as a popup help item when I get time, so it can't accidentally be deleted by wayward web designers.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/dave0/leaguerunner/issues/78#issuecomment-20730295 .