search

davidavdav / GaussianMixtures.jl

Large scale Gaussian Mixture Models
Other
95 stars 36 forks source link

`Distributions.jl` in compat section #94

Closed kirill-kondrashov closed 2 years ago

kirill-kondrashov commented 2 years ago

I've recently bumped into a problem trying to install GaussinMixtures.jl together with a few other packages, because of strict compat section in Project.toml, in particular the constrains related to Distributions.jl. In my project GaussianMixtures.jl successfully coexists with Distributions.jl@v0.25.16. I suggest easing this constraint.

ForceBru commented 2 years ago

Same thing with PDMats: the latest version is v0.11.1, but installing GaussianMixtures.jl downgrades it to v0.11.1.

As a side note, I find it odd that installing one package can easily downgrade my installed packages without warning, sometimes several major versions down, such that they no longer provide the features my code uses, so my code breaks because I installed some other package.

davidavdav commented 2 years ago

Hi, yes this is a place in dependency hell that I haven't visited a lot. I think there is a whole Julia / github infrastructure for getting notified when there are new versions of dependencies, but I think it explicitly doesn't do testing, so I've turned all these things off as it appears useless to me.

I am happy to update these compatibility restrictions to something that has been tested to work.

Specifically for Distributions.jl the dependency isn't very strict, I think that this package only has an export function for Distributions, it doesn't functionally depend on it.

yuehhua commented 2 years ago

I have this package as dependency for my own package. I found it is blocked by Distributions.jl version rooted in this package. I hope these compats can be picked up and get package maintained well.