search

davidmoreno / rtpmidid

RTP MIDI (AppleMIDI) daemon for Linux
Other
183 stars 41 forks source link

Update Readme #90

Closed AbrahamWisman closed 2 years ago

AbrahamWisman commented 2 years ago

Added my alternative Android apps that connect with RTP.

davidmoreno commented 2 years ago

Merged!

If you have a similar list of related rtpmidi projects, I would very much appreciate a link back too!

davidmoreno commented 2 years ago

Hi,

just tried MIDI connector Free, and could not connect. I think it does the first packet connection, maybe control channel, but then fails, maybe at connecting the MIDI channel.

If you could have a look and we can fix it, if not I might have to mark both MIDI Connection and MIDI Hub as non compatible implementations.

If there is something I can do to make it work, tell me.

Regards, David.

AbrahamWisman commented 2 years ago

Hi,

For me they do seem to work. However I do not get any confirmation that the connection has been completed. I use a third-party library for my apps that takes care of the rtpmidi functionality.

I found that when I initiate a connection from any of my apps with rtpMIDI for windows from Tobias Erichsen, I receive a "confirmation" that it has been connected. -> Connect to address:port -> Connected to address:port

But when initiate a connection from any of my apps with this deamon I get no "confirmation" -> Connect to address:port

Regardless of the confirmation, I can send MIDI from my Android and receive it on the deamon. MIDI Hub's UI however will not show the deamon as connected since it never got the confirmation. MIDI Connector's UI just shows me that it is connected without the need of a confirmation.

I am not sure what you saw when you tried MIDI Connector and it failed.
I can get you a free copy of MIDI Hub if desired.

My setup Raspberry Pi with rtpmidid version 21.11~2~g0e172 Android 11 The rtpmidi library i use is developed by Nils Peters from xmmc. Same developer as Touchdaw.