Custom splits

[cpiber]

Currently column_default_width and window_default_height take a fixed set of strings. I think it could be nice to be able to specify custom percentages (keeping support for the existing options of course). I'm interested in working on it, but want to hear your opinion first.

[dawsers]

What would you use this for? I would like to understand the use case first. The reason why there are only a few preset values is they can mostly be combined to add up to the width or height of the screen, so the movements are cleaner (1/3+2/3 or 1/4+1/4+1/2 etc.). Allowing let's say 17% would make things a bit messier in terms of user experience, in my opinion. That is why I am interested in your use case, so I can understand the need for this.

[cpiber]

PaperWM allows custom values, and I like 80% to 85% (small monitor). You currently only allow 75% or full width, so often I feel the window is either slightly too small or it takes the entire width, which isn't perfect either

[dawsers]

So you probably want to use the remaining 15-20% for a messaging up, file manager or similar. I understand.

I work with just 3-4 sizes,so cycling is faster. So the way I do it is I have a 2/3 window and a 1/6, hit Super+w + Down and the two windows become 80% and 20%, and fit the monitor exactly. Super+W is a submap for scroller:fitsize, and Down means all, but I can also use w instead of Down if I just want the visible ones (when there are more than those two). A similar submap is in the README.

(2/3) / (2/3 + 1/6) = 4/5 = 80%

fitsize is quite powerful, and often overlooked because PaperWM doesn't support it (at least when I was using it, a few months ago).

I find working on simple fractions easier because most times you want the monitor to fit full windows (an integer number of them), and fitsize helps with those cases when the few fractional widths I use aren't enough.

When all that isn't enough, there is Super+Shift+R which I map to resize (similar to the README), That is slower, but allows me to resize a window to the pixel.

If you think it would be useful to have more fractions, like `ThreeQuarters or even fifths I could add them, but my initial inclination is allowing any width would add complexity (there are also roundings going on internally) and confusion to non-power users. But I am open to discuss it.

[cpiber]

I think you're using the extension quite differently from me. My main use is just to scroll horizontally, I rarely use fitsize, since I actually want the windows to be larger than the screen. I just want to have several windows each at 80%, and then scroll left and right through them, similar to a group in regular Hyprland but nicer.

As mentioned, I would keep the existing words, and just allow the user to specify a number as well. I don't think that that will introduce additional problems, since you need to convert it to a float for screen space anyways (in update_height/update_width). But if you're against it, I'd appreciate a FourFifths ^^

[dawsers]

Got it. It is always good to know how people are using the plugin, especially because there are not too many users.That way, I try to accommodate requests, but still avoid getting into hairy business. In my opinion, custom splits introduce more parsing (which I don't like), and unbalanced combinations, for a simple use case like yours. So I will add more fractions, some fourths and fifths, which will also be useful for people with ultra-wide monitors, and your use case will hopefully be covered too (FourFifths will definitely be in).

In the future, if things get too complicated and there are more complex use cases, I may remove all the string fractions and change to numbers, so people can do whatever they want, but I think for now there is probably no need to go nuclear.

Thank you for your input. You have always been very helpful.

[dawsers]

I have added ThreeQuarters and FiveSixths in 915abf416d2d1e4a946d1198f2c1ede47f83c4d6. These two values will allow better handling of fourths and sixths window configurations, while allowing you to have an 83% width window (fivesixths). It is similar to what you said would be good for you (80-85%), and more useful in general for sixths configurations instead of adding another configuration of fifths. Now people can handle any width or height in multiples of 1/4 and 1/6.

I will leave this issue open to acknowledge the discussion about custom sizes, and maybe revisit or implement it in the future.

[cpiber]

Perfect, thank you!