Closed swider33 closed 9 years ago
db0
commented
9 years ago Is this something new, or have you seen it in previous updates. I've never seen anything like before. Of course for shotgun and coachwhip, that;s normal since they take the dude's items with them. But Hex slinging should discard the spell, even if you target a dude by mistake,
Can you find a replicatable scenario for me to test?
swider33
commented
9 years ago The bug is quite old, I am pretty sure that I saw it pre-NTNR. I think I described the bug incorrectly so I will do it again. Basically, after using one of those cards, more than one dude becomes discarded/aced, usually the dude that was an owner of the goods.Also it discards/aces extra dudes, even if only one card on a map is targeted. Strange thing is that when you manually bring them back to the board it is sometimes impossible for a moment to reattach the goods to a dude. It works only on n-th try. And again sometimes when you ace a dude in a shootout, he spawns at home.
Sometimes the bug "snowballs" and dudes/deeds start disappearing practically after every play, although this is really rare.
When it comes to hex slingin', I didn't use it in a while, also people don't play 4th ring recently, but what usually happened was that the wrong spell got discarded on playing it. If you want to replicate the bug I would suggest to create two big posses and use cards effects on dudes in those posses. I will try to recreate the bug myself, if I succeed or see it online again, I will describe it to you as well as it is possible.
Thank you for answering, and all the fixes you have done yesterday. Fantastic job.
On Tue, Dec 16, 2014 at 12:53 PM, Divided by Zer0 notifications@github.com wrote:
Is this something new, or have you seen it in previous updates. I've never seen anything like before. Of course for shotgun and coachwhip, that;s normal since they take the dude's items with them. But Hex slinging should discard the spell, even if you target a dude by mistake,
Can you find a replicatable scenario for me to test?
— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/db0/Doomtown-Reloaded-OCTGN/issues/8#issuecomment-67155074 .
db0
commented
9 years ago OK, if it happens, try to copy paste the log to me in a pastebin so that I can take a look.
db0
commented
9 years ago Still didn't happen again?
swider33
commented
9 years ago I haven't noticed this email yesterday. I think the bug was created by targeting more than one card when card's effect was discarding/aceing a card. I haven't seen this bug snowballing since reporting it. Constraining a type and/or a number of cards targeted by a card that discards or aces other cards might be a good idea. While it is quite easy to manualy reverse a created problem , sometimes a card removed from the table, for instance a huckster, has other cards attached to it that have various state ( booted / unbooted), and recovering the state of all of those cards is sometimes hard. On 24 Jan 2015 11:09, "Divided by Zer0" notifications@github.com wrote:
Closed #8 https://github.com/db0/Doomtown-Reloaded-OCTGN/issues/8.
— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/db0/Doomtown-Reloaded-OCTGN/issues/8#event-224139670.
db0
commented
9 years ago Cards are already constrained, but if you target two dudes with coachwhip and one is wrong, then there's really nothing I can do
On Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 1:19 PM, swider33 notifications@github.com wrote:
I haven't noticed this email yesterday. I think the bug was created by targeting more than one card when card's effect was discarding/aceing a card. I haven't seen this bug snowballing since reporting it. Constraining a type and/or a number of cards targeted by a card that discards or aces other cards might be a good idea. While it is quite easy to manualy reverse a created problem , sometimes a card removed from the table, for instance a huckster, has other cards attached to it that have various state ( booted / unbooted), and recovering the state of all of those cards is sometimes hard. On 24 Jan 2015 11:09, "Divided by Zer0" notifications@github.com wrote:
Closed #8 https://github.com/db0/Doomtown-Reloaded-OCTGN/issues/8.
— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/db0/Doomtown-Reloaded-OCTGN/issues/8#event-224139670.
— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/db0/Doomtown-Reloaded-OCTGN/issues/8#issuecomment-71314411 .
Items and cards that cause discard or ace other cards sometimes trigger on random cards. Examples of items that are causing it: shotgun,coachwhip, hex slingin'. It happens quite often that if those items are used, the dude that has them on itself is discarded or aced alongside intended target of the card. Very often the goods card " refuses" to be reattached when a player tries to fix a bug manually. Also in some games deeds start to disappear from the map at random, I am not sure if it is connected to above mentioned bug, but I think so.