dbpedia / lookup

Outputs a list of ranked DBpedia resources for a search string.
Apache License 2.0
185 stars 39 forks source link

different results in public API and in local server #36

Closed vefthym closed 8 years ago

vefthym commented 8 years ago

Hi, when I execute the query:

http://localhost:1111/api/search/KeywordSearch?QueryClass=&QueryString=berlin

in my localhost, I get different results than those on the public server, as shown below (only the URIs of the results are shown here for easier reading). Is it an issue of different versions? Which one is running on the public server?

  <URI>http://dbpedia.org/resource/Dada</URI>
  <URI>http://dbpedia.org/resource/Central_European_Time</URI>
  <URI>http://dbpedia.org/resource/Kingdom_of_Prussia</URI>
  <URI>http://dbpedia.org/resource/Golden_Bear</URI>
  <URI>http://dbpedia.org/resource/Spandau</URI>
sandroacoelho commented 8 years ago

Hi @jimkont . Could you give a hand here?

Thanks

boyarintsev commented 8 years ago

I've got the same issue. First thought I cannot pass the correct index, but after some testing it looks good. Could it be the problem with the index bundle 2015-04 itself? Will appreciate any help a lot!

boyarintsev commented 8 years ago

Hi @vefthym ! May I ask you, have you found a solution?

sandroacoelho commented 8 years ago

Hi @boyarintsev ,

Maybe can be a problem with 2015-04. I can rebuild it and make available 2015-10 and 2016-04. Could you, please, provide us more examples of the problems that you are facing?

boyarintsev commented 8 years ago

Hi @sandroacoelho !

I'm just getting different sets of results from the demo and from the local instance. Or maybe I'm missing something. demo local

sandroacoelho commented 8 years ago

Hi @boyarintsev . It's a bug in our index. I will check it ASAP.

boyarintsev commented 8 years ago

Thanks a lot, Sandro!

sandroacoelho commented 8 years ago

Hi @boyarintsev , @vefthym

It's done. Please try

docker run -p 1111:1111 -it dbpedia/lookup java -jar /opt/lookup/dbpedia-lookup-3.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar /opt/lookup/2015-10/

I forgot to include instance files (instance_types_en.ttl, instance_types_sdtyped_dbo_en.ttl, instance_types_transitive_en.ttl) into the index. I've updated our README with these new instructions.

Best,

boyarintsev commented 8 years ago

Hi @sandroacoelho , It works! Thanks a lot.

I will appreciate a lot if you could answer one more question. Is there a way to obtain some measure of how the system is sure in the result provided. For instance, us -> United States of America (95%)

Thanks, Alex

vefthym commented 8 years ago

Hi @sandroacoelho and @boyarintsev,

thanks for taking care of that. I do not have time at this point to check it, but since both of you reproduced the same issue as me and it now works for both, I believe you can close the issue.

Thanks for fixing that! Vasilis

sandroacoelho commented 8 years ago

Hi @boyarintsev ,

Great to hear that is working now.

will appreciate a lot if you could answer one more question. Is there a way to obtain some measure of how the system is sure in the result provided. For instance, us -> United States of America (95%)

Yes, It's possible. Let's open a new issue to talk about it

sandroacoelho commented 8 years ago

Hi @boyarintsev ,

I have opened a new issue #43.

I have a vague idea on how to do it. I will share there and then we can discuss.

Best,