dckiller51 / bodymiscale

Custom_components Body Metrics for Xiaomi Miscale 1 and 2 (esphome or BLE monitor for Homeassistant)
Apache License 2.0
204 stars 32 forks source link

Incorrect womens calculations #221

Closed luigi311 closed 7 months ago

luigi311 commented 8 months ago

Looks like there are some issues with the womens calculations, male seems spot on as all my numbers are correct but my SO some of the numbers are off by a significant amount. I can provide you a list of what zepp reports and what this is reporting if needed via email so i dont paste it all in here since i doubt she would like that lol, email me at git@luigi311.com

Visceral Fat is off by 4 Body fat by 11 protein by 3 water by 8 muscle mass by 19 ideal by 5 basal metabolism by 323 metabolic age by 20

dckiller51 commented 7 months ago

Hi, thanks for your data. After checking your ZEPP data corresponds to the male equivalent and not for a woman. Can you check again in your application?

dckiller51 commented 7 months ago

@luigi311 Hello, were you able to check your Zepp application?

luigi311 commented 7 months ago

For some reason i cant get anything to change in the zepp application. I have my SO as a separate profile in my account by clicking on the + and putting in her information. I select female and I still get the exact same numbers, i click on + again and see her profile and it shows male as sex and changing it doesnt seem to do anything as the numbers are the same and going back into that setting shows male again.

dckiller51 commented 7 months ago

@luigi311 Hi, I just did my own tests. I don't see any problems. I'm going to close post. I enclose my tests.

Consolidation of results Comparatif

ZEPP Man Zepp Man

Bodymiscale Man Bodymiscale Man

ZEPP Woman ZEPP Woman

Bodymiscale Woman Bodymiscale Woman