dcpurton / biblatex-sbl

Society of Biblical Literature (SBL) style files for biblatex
24 stars 5 forks source link

Duplicate abbreviations entries #126

Closed lyndondrake closed 3 years ago

lyndondrake commented 3 years ago

Hi,

I have a few instances in my bibliography file which show up in the Abbreviation list twice. In this bib file (generated from Zotero via Better BibLaTeX), if I leave the shortseries field off Stipp2010, the abbreviation list has no duplicates, but as soon as I add that field in, I get VTSup twice in the abbreviation list. The relevant bit of LaTeX is below too.

Any ideas? I've been scratching my head for quite a while on this (and two others which I assume are something similar).

Best, Lyndon

The bib entries:

@book{Emerton2010,
  title = {Genesis, {{Isaiah}}, and {{Psalms}}: {{A}} Festschrift to Honour {{Professor John Emerton}} for His Eightieth Birthday},
  shorttitle = {Genesis, {{Isaiah}}, and {{Psalms}}},
  editor = {Emerton, J. A. and Dell, Katharine J. and Davies, Graham I. and Koh, Y. V.},
  date = {2010},
  series = {Supplements to {{Vetus Testamentum}}},
  number = {135},
  publisher = {{Brill}},
  location = {{Leiden ; Boston}},
  abstract = {The story of Paradise in the light of Mesopotamian culture and literature / Arie van der Kooij -- Nimrod's cities: an item from the Rolling Corpus / Terry Fenton -- Power or inheritance: a constructive comparison of Genesis 16 and Genesis 21 / Ina Willi-Plein -- The Nabatean "God of the Fathers" / John F. Healey -- The transition from Genesis to Exodus / Graham Davies -- Novelists as interpreters of Genesis / Bertil Albrektson -- Isaiah as a prophet to Samaria and his memoirs / Menahem Haran -- Take a large writing tablet and write on it: Isaiah--a writing prophet? / Alan Millard -- The Suffering Servant of Deutero-Isaiah: Jeremiah revisited / Katharine J. Dell -- God and the gods: pagan deities and religious concepts in the Old Greek of Isaiah / Joachim Schaper -- Frants Buhl as an Old Testament scholar: the Isaiah commentary in Danish / Knud Jeppesen -- Editorial arrangement in Book IV of the Psalter / Anthony Gelston -- An appraisal of G. H. Wilson's theories on the organization of the Masoretic Psalter / Yee Von Koh -- Psalm 93: a historical and comparative survey of its Jewish interpretation / Stefan C. Reif -- Gregory of Nyssa: the superscriptions of the Psalms / Patrick D. Miller -- Wellhausen on the Psalms / Rudolf Smend.},
  isbn = {978-90-04-18231-8},
  langid = {english},
  pagetotal = {xx+261},
  shortseries = {VTSup},
  keywords = {event:confirmation},
  file = {/Users/lyndon/Documents/Media/Bookshelf/Emerton2010 Genesis, Isaiah, and Psalms.pdf}
}
%
@incollection{Leuchter2018,
  title = {The Pen of Scribes: {{Writing}}, Textuality, and the {{Book}} of {{Jeremiah}}},
  booktitle = {The Book of {{Jeremiah}}: {{Composition}}, Reception, and Interpretation},
  author = {Leuchter, Mark},
  editor = {Lundbom, Jack R. and Evans, Craig A. and Anderson, Bradford A.},
  date = {2018},
  series = {Supplements to {{Vetus Testamentum}}},
  number = {178},
  pages = {3--25},
  publisher = {{Brill}},
  location = {{Leiden}},
  isbn = {978-90-04-37326-6},
  langid = {english},
  shortseries = {VTSup},
  keywords = {@BookPDF,event:confirmation}
}

@collection{Lundbom2018,
  title = {The Book of {{Jeremiah}}: {{Composition}}, Reception, and Interpretation},
  shorttitle = {The {{Book}} of {{Jeremiah}}},
  editor = {Lundbom, Jack R. and Evans, Craig A. and Anderson, Bradford A.},
  date = {2018},
  series = {Supplements to {{Vetus Testamentum}}},
  number = {178},
  publisher = {{Brill}},
  location = {{Leiden}},
  abstract = {Part 1. General topics -- Part 2. Issues in interpretation -- Part 3. Textual transmission and reception history -- Part 4. Jeremiah and theology.},
  isbn = {978-90-04-37326-6},
  langid = {english},
  shortseries = {VTSup},
  keywords = {event:confirmation},
  file = {/Users/lyndon/Documents/Media/Bookshelf/Lundbom2018 The book of Jeremiah.pdf}
}

@incollection{Stipp2010,
  title = {Das judäische und das babylonische Jeremiabuch},
  booktitle = {Congress volume Ljubljana 2007},
  author = {Stipp, Hermann-Josef},
  editor = {Lemaire, André},
  date = {2010},
  series = {Supplements to Vetus Testamentum},
  number = {133},
  pages = {239--264},
  publisher = {{Brill}},
  location = {{Leiden}},
  abstract = {Transmission of Semitic forms of Biblical proper names in Greek and Latin linguistic traditions / Jože Krašovec -- The Genesis of Genesis / David L. Petersen -- Das Rätsel von Psalm 49 / Gianni Barbiero -- Masora's contribution to Biblical studies : revival of an ancient tool / Aron Dotan -- Retouches rédactionnelles au texte proto-massorétique : l'apport des versions grecques de Daniel / Olivier Munnich -- The challenge of Hebrew lexicography today / David J.A. Clines -- An integrated verb system for Biblical Hebrew prose and poetry / Alviero Nicacci -- Zwischen Elephantine und Qumran : das Alte Testament im Rahmen des antiken Judentums / Reinhard G. Kratz -- The earliest known manuscripts of Samaritan Arabic Chronicles and other texts in the Russian National Library in St. Petersburg / Haroutyun S. Jamgotchian -- The coincidental textual nature of the collections of ancient scriptures / Emanuel Tov --, The significance of the pre-Maccabean literature from the Qumran library for the understanding of the Hebrew Bible / Armin Lange -- Gebete als hermeneutischer Schlüssel zu biblischen Büchern, am Beispiel von Jeremia / Georg Fischer -- Das judäische und das babylonische Jeremiabuch / Hermann-Josef Stipp -- Konstantinos Oikonomos ex Oikonomon als Septuaginta-Interpret / Evangelia G. Dafni -- Principles of Orthodox hermeneutics / Vasile Mihoc -- The forgotten divinity of creation : suggestions for a revision of Old Testament creation theology in the 21st century / Silvia Schroer -- Philosophical interpretations of the sacrifice of Issac / Seizō Sekine -- Reading texts holistically : the foundation of Biblical criticism / John Barton -- La persuasion coopérative dans le discours sur la loi : pour une analyse de la rhétorique du Code de Sainteté / Jan Joosten -- The creation of man in 2 (Slavonic) Enoch and in Christian tradition /, Grant Macaskill -- The impact of interpretation on the evolution of the Church Slavonic Psalter text up to the fifteenth century / Catherine Mary MacRobert -- Biblical prophecy from a Near Eastern perspective : the cases of kingship and divine possession / Martti Nissinen -- God's repentance and "false starts" in Biblical history (Genesis 6-9; Exodus 32-34; 1 Samuel 15 and 2 Samuel 7) / Jean-Pierre Sonnet -- Hope in two keys : musical impact and the poetics of Job 14 / C.-L. Seow -- Messianic passages of the Book of Sirach in the translation of St. Methodius / Svetlina Nikolova -- The perception of God's house in the Psalter : a study of how the Psalmists understand the Temple / Mary Jerome Obiorah -- The Second Commandment and "true worship" in the Iconoclastic Controversy / Vladimir Baranov -- Ezekiel's debate with Isaiah / Marvin A. Sweeney -- Farewell to Deutero-Isaiah, or Prophecy without a prophet / Ulrich Berges --, Fondements du message social des prophètes / Francolino J. Gonçalves -- Towards the formulation of a theology of the Septuagint / Johann Cook.},
  isbn = {978-90-04-17977-6},
  langid = {eng;fre;ger;gre;heb},
  shortseries = {VTSup},
  keywords = {event:confirmation,lang:Deutsch},
  file = {/Users/lyndon/Documents/Media/Bookshelf/Stipp2010 Das judaische und das babylonische Jeremiabuch.pdf}
}

and the LaTeX code:

\begin{document}

\author{Lyndon Drake}
\date{\today}
\title{Bibliography: Confirmation of Status}

\maketitle

\nocite{*}

\printbibliography[filter=primary,title={Primary texts}]

\printbibliography[filter=commentaries,title=Commentaries]

\printbibliography[filter=major,title={Works on Jeremiah 32}]

\printbibliography[filter=others,title={General works}]

\printbiblist{abbreviations}

\end{document}
lyndondrake commented 3 years ago

Aargh, just realised it's the case protection from Better BibLaTeX being inconsistently applied. I'll file over there instead.