search

deanwillis / p2psip-base-master

Master copy of P2PSIP Base draft
0 stars 0 forks source link

Gen-ART 41 #172

Closed deanwillis closed 11 years ago

deanwillis commented 11 years ago

From: Mary Barnes

Description: Section 10.1 [11.1] - 4th para after the element list states that "All of the non optional values MUST be provided". However, the list of elements in the previous paragraph are not specifically identified as non optional. I think the first 3 are mandatory. So, I would suggest to re-word the 3rd paragraph as follows and delete the 1st sentence in the 4th paragraph noted above: OLD: In addition, the kind element contains the following elements: max-count: the maximum number of values which members of the overlay must support. data-model: the data model to be used. max-size: the maximum size of individual values. access-control: the access control model to be used. max-node-multiple: This is optional and only used when the access control is NODE-MULTIPLE. This indicates the maximum value for the i counter. This is an integer greater than 0.

NEW: In addition, the kind element MUST contain the following elements: max-count: the maximum number of values which members of the overlay must support. data-model: the data model to be used. max-size: the maximum size of individual values. access-control: the access control model to be used.

The kind element MAY also contain the following element:
max-node-multiple:  if the access control is NODE-MULTIPLE, 
   this element MAY be included. This indicates the maximum value for
   the i counter.  It MUST be an integer greater than 0.

Notes: Will fix text as suggested.

petithug commented 11 years ago

Comment from Cullen: we should talk about this but my assumption was that the "MAY" in 6993 was meant to be a "MUST". I don't really care but otherwise you don't know how a value of i to of try and test to.