Open jcea opened 4 years ago
cseelye
commented
4 years ago Are your patches available to look at/try out? I would like to do the exact scenario you are describing so that I can install/reinstall a group of Pis without touching the SD cards.
diederikdehaas
commented
4 years ago It could potentially be interesting. One problem is that I have no experience with PXE and I don't tend to include things I haven't tried myself. Also, I don't have a RPi4 and I don't know if or when I will get one. I do have RPi3B+'s.
Supporting older raspberry PI models. This would require to use a preconfigured microSD with updated firmware, and in this situation you could just write on it a regular "raspbian-ua-netinst". PXE boot could be useful for some usecases, maybe.
"preconfigured microSD with updated firmware" scares me a bit and may cause me to reject this idea. So you'd have to provide details that would/could convince me. Even though this project isn't Reproducable, I do find that principle very important.
Raspberry PI 3B+ and 4B (and previous models with a microSD with a up to date firmware) can boot via PXE. That is, boot from network.
I have a minimal patch to this project to create files suitable for PXE boot, when booting a Raspberry PI 3B+.
You store those files in a PXE server, boot your raspberry pi with a blank microSD and the raspberry PI 3B+ will boot a (small) variant of this project from network and then do a regular raspbian install.
That is, you can deploy a raspberry with blank microSDs. You don't need to plug the microSD first to a computer and flash "raspbian-ua-netinst" to it.
Current state works perfectly fine and fullfills my needs. The changes, nevertheless, are so small and trivial that I think that this project would be interested. Current state is fine for me, but would need some work before a pull request. I would do that work if this project is interested in PXE booting.
Pending improvements:
Being able of configuring installation using the regular configuration files. Not implemented yet because I don't need it, but easy to do.
Supporting Raspberry Pi 4B. I will have access to my 4B in october. Somebody else could try before that time.
Supporting older raspberry PI models. This would require to use a preconfigured microSD with updated firmware, and in this situation you could just write on it a regular "raspbian-ua-netinst". PXE boot could be useful for some usecases, maybe.
For some reason I don't understand, I need to explicitly load the "lan78xx" driver (the Ethernet driver in Raspberry 3B+) in my patch in order to be able to enable networking. I don't know why it is not needed when booting from the microSD card. Would be nice to investigate & resolve. I don't know the possible negative impact if trying to "modprobe" that module in a different raspberry PI model.
To sum up, would you be interested in expanding "raspbian-ua-netinst" to generate PXE files?