decentralized-identity / credential-manifest

Format that normalizes the definition of requirements for the issuance of a credential
https://identity.foundation/credential-manifest/
Apache License 2.0
29 stars 22 forks source link

Credential Application Top-Level Format Property: Unnecessary? #111

Closed decentralgabe closed 2 years ago

decentralgabe commented 2 years ago

The credential_application MUST have a format property if the related Credential Manifest specifies a format property. Its value MUST be a subset of the format property in the Credential Manifest that this Credential Submission is related to. This object informs the Issuer which formats the Holder wants to recieve the Claims in.

If the presentation submission has claims, and those claims have format properties in the descriptor map...what is the purpose / utility of having the format properties distinct from the claims themselves?

csuwildcat commented 2 years ago

This is about what formats the Issuer should issue the applicant credentials in, vs the Descriptor formats, which describe what formats an Issuer accepts for evaluation.

decentralgabe commented 2 years ago

Ah, my misunderstanding.