Version 3 onion services are unreachable

isuldor commented 4 years ago

I believe dcrwallet already supports onion HiddenServiceVersion 3, because the address for CSPP is 6i6otcms7mxhnmqf5uclj6tot4gd6dsgk3twnfefssh7v7pbqs57umqd.onion. So I had expected dcrd also supported HSv3. I attempted to set up dcrd 1.5 in bridge mode, as described in docs/configuring_tor.md. But I got the error

[WRN] SRVR: Not adding 4mcqdwmx5b5dvfl6imumomqifypwctsgneppdslw7cjwvrvrogzigtad.onion as externalip: tor host is unreachable

I am able to workaround this issue by configuring HiddenServiceVersion 2 and using that instead.

davecgh commented 4 years ago

Correct. They are not supported and doing so is a pretty hard change because the addr message format doesn't have enough space to support addresses that large.

chappjc commented 4 years ago

Can the issue remain open?

dajohi commented 4 years ago

https://github.com/rahra/onioncat/commit/a145dc176ef3758bfeb48f70d59a9c97f7819b1b

dajohi commented 4 years ago

https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0155.mediawiki#Appendix_B_Tor_v3_address_encoding

sefbkn commented 3 years ago

Picking this one up.

decred / dcrd

Version 3 onion services are unreachable #2035