xaur
commented
5 years ago Good findings! Edited issue source a bit.
Page 12: Section below seems confusing. doesn’t really make clear if Treasury is controlled by DAO or DHG, seems to contradict itself. Also mentions on chain vote while Politeia votes are offchain, and mentions smart contracts for DAE. Can anyone clear if this is correct?
Correct, Politeia is all off-chain, no on-chain voting for fund allocations exist.
Correction: The section is talking about Politeia. It should be made clear that DAE will be implemented in future and right now DHG does the payments. It mentions both as if they are both happening. Does DCC automates a part of this?
iirc DCC will automate invoicing, reporting, and maybe semi-automate payments in a sense of improving accountant's productivity, but ultimately the trigger will still be manual until DAE smart contracts are implemented.
There are multiple mistakes/omissions in recently released Decred: Deep Dive Report (PDF) by Smith + Crown.
[ ] Page 8: "The last block reward will be created in 2039; afterward, the network will be secured by transaction fees alone."
Correction: Per the docs, "The last block reward will be created in September 2120. The upper limit on the total supply of Decred is 20,999,999.99800912 coins"
[ ] Page 12: Section below seems confusing. doesn’t really make clear if Treasury is controlled by DAO or DHG, seems to contradict itself. Also mentions on-chain vote while Politeia votes are off-chain, and mentions smart contracts for DAE, which are not implemented yet.
Correction: The section is talking about Politeia. It should be made clear that DAE will be implemented in future and right now DHG does the payments. It mentions both as if they are both happening. Does DCC automates a part of this?
they do clear the ambiguity on Page 16
[ ] Page 13: Completely fails to mention PoS component that enables all the distinguishing features mentioned and makes the chain more secure against attacks
[ ] Page 16: Misses the fact that payments are made in arrears and deliverables/milestones are expected for proposals/payments.
[ ] No mention of fork resistance due to PoW/PoS Hybrid system (more links here). This is a major omission.