search

decrypto-org / blockchain-papers

A curated list of academic blockchain-related papers
2.44k stars 555 forks source link

Paywall policy #98

Open dionyziz opened 5 years ago

dionyziz commented 5 years ago

How do we feel about papers behind paywalls? Do we want to link to paywalls? Do we want to update our policy so that we mandate every paper we link to is available openly?

OrfeasLitos commented 5 years ago

I'm against links to paywalls. If a published paper is behind a paywall, I support linking to an open version of it (e.g. author's website). Let's hear more opinions before updating the policy though.

dionyziz commented 5 years ago

My opinion is that we should forbid links to paywalled sites completely. Only papers that have an open version available should be listed in our curated list, and only when the link provided is to the open version. The author's website is one option; ePrint and arXiv are another.

montyly commented 5 years ago

Alternatively, a paper can have two links, one to the processing/original version (which could be behind a paywall), and one to a public (potentially updated) version.

I do agree that a paper should always have a public link.

OrfeasLitos commented 5 years ago

I agree with @dionyziz in boycotting paywalled sites. I agree with @montyly in linking to 2 versions. See #99 for a discussion on the latter.

dionyziz commented 5 years ago

I don't mind providing two versions. Sounds good. If @dimkarakostas is also in agreement we can incorporate this policy to our contributions guideline.

The question that remains is for the formatting of these two links.

dimkarakostas commented 5 years ago

I'm fine with the two links.

cnasikas commented 5 years ago

I am also fine with the two links.