search

deflomu / Roundcube-SMTP-per-Identity-Plugin

Roundcube plugin to setup different SMTP settings per identity
MIT License
44 stars 19 forks source link

After upgrade to Roundcube 1.5.2 always SMTP server from config.inc.php is used #27

Closed mercury1337 closed 2 years ago

mercury1337 commented 2 years ago

I upgraded to RCM 1.5.2 and since then the plugin does no longer work for me. After the upgrade the SMTP server strings were empty in RCM and I had to add them again. But then I noticed that no matter what I had configured always the SMTP server from config.inc.php is used (had to enable SMTP debugging to see the problem in the logs) Enabling / disabling identities did not help and also adding new ones shows the same behavior.

I am using identity plugin 1.0.0 from packagist

HannesJo0139 commented 2 years ago

I can reproduce it. Did you do any further debugging? Maybe a small change could do the trick.

mercury1337 commented 2 years ago

No, sorry - I'm no developer.

HannesJo0139 commented 2 years ago

I've figured it out. Pull Request https://github.com/deflomu/Roundcube-SMTP-per-Identity-Plugin/pull/26 updates the server address scheme to how it is stored in Roundcube 1.6 Beta. Unfortunately the new maintainer has just applied these changes to the master branch without taking care of different versions.

Long story short: If you installed the plugin using git clone, just go into the plugin directory and execute 

git checkout 23f57b63d4cb0b3e24d7c2dbc4fea5977eaff730

This will revert all changes made after PR https://github.com/deflomu/Roundcube-SMTP-per-Identity-Plugin/pull/23. You will have to re-enter the smtp server addresses at identity settings and everything should work again.

I suggest leaving the issue open until the repository is being configured properly. Oh and maybe rename it to 'Plugin broken for Roundcube v < 1.6 beta' or sth like that :)

tihhgoncalves commented 2 years ago

I was having the same problem and with the suggestion you gave I managed to make it work. Thanks a lot for the help! :)

NotActuallyTerry commented 2 years ago

Hey! Sorry about that, I didn't get pinged for this for some reason. I've added tags through the repo for corresponding Roundcube versions, they should sync across to Packagist soon. I'll leave this open until they do sync.

HannesJo0139 commented 2 years ago

Nice, thank you 🙏

NotActuallyTerry commented 2 years ago

@deflomu Are you able to check why Packagist isn't pulling the new tags in?

deflomu commented 2 years ago

I think the tags cannot be parsed by packagist. They write here how version tags must look: https://packagist.org/about

NotActuallyTerry commented 2 years ago

Alright, I've updated the tags to follow semver (copying RC's major+minor to our major+minor) so they should sync over

mercury1337 commented 2 years ago

Packagist still has the old package :-(

NotActuallyTerry commented 2 years ago

It appears to be synced over now! No idea why it took Packagist so long to pick up on them but oh well

mercury1337 commented 2 years ago

Got "dev-master" from packagist today - still the same behavior :-(

NotActuallyTerry commented 2 years ago

My bad, I should've been a bit clearer, you'll want to pull version 1.5.0 from Packagist.

mercury1337 commented 2 years ago

Thx a lot - it works now! Thanks for all your hard work!

HannesJo0139 commented 2 years ago

Please update the README with correct tags as well :) git checkout 1.0.0-1.6 => git checkout 1.6.0

NotActuallyTerry commented 2 years ago

Updated!

Henri-J-Norden commented 2 years ago

You might want to make it more obvious that the version number must correspond with your Roundcube version... Right now it is not even stated in the README and I had to read these github issues to figure out why it's not working... apparently iRedMail still ships with 1.5.2. I did not encounter such a problem installing the latest version of other plugins though, so I don't feel like this is an common/obvious way of doing things 😕