dektronics / printalyzer-timer

F-Stop enlarging timer and print exposure meter
24 stars 6 forks source link

Fix power switch cable connector size and placement #52

Closed dkonigsberg closed 4 months ago

dkonigsberg commented 5 months ago

The power board (Rev C) currently uses a Molex 768290002 Mega-Fit 5.7mm pitch connector, combined with a Molex 451360201 cable assembly (cut in half, with QC connectors crimped on) as a way of attaching the power switch.

In the current revision of the board, this arrangement has the following problems:

This absolutely needs to be fixed, sooner rather than later, The current proposed approach towards fixing the issue is as follows:

The main challenge with smaller and/or more reasonable connectors is simply that the pins are closer together than we'd like for trace clearance. As such, extra layout/routing care may be necessary.

dkonigsberg commented 5 months ago

One simple solution would be to not use the noted cable assembly, which uses 12AWG wires, and instead simply buy the components to make a 16AWG assembly:

A bit challenge with selecting any options is wanting sufficient clearance between the pins, and being able to find pre-crimped leads that match the system.

dkonigsberg commented 4 months ago

The other solution, now likely for the next revision, is to change to a smaller connector. The Molex Mega-Fit stack puts the top of the plug 28.8mm above the PCB, plus whatever space the cable bend takes.

The alternative now being considered is the Molex Mini-Fit Jr series. With this connector, the stack puts the top of the plug only 23.5mm above the PCB (plus cable bend). While only a ~5mm difference, when combined with the ease of repositioning a smaller connector, this should be more than enough. The only downside is that the lowest common rating of the Mini-Fit components is only 9A per contact. However, we're fusing at 5-6A, so that should be fine. Will still stick to 16 AWG wires, for better flexibility.