Laravel 5.5 - data is stored as decrypted after model update

[bjauy]

I have been testing this package for few days on Laravel 5.5. Recently, I've checked table content and some of the rows weren't encrypted at all.

After few tests in artisan tinker I've nailed the issue to updates that make the data unencrypted. Model creation works as expected.

The problem happens also in default L5.5 installation, using MySQL (MariaDB 10.1.26 exactly):

1. Database and package setup:

   composer create-project --prefer-dist laravel/laravel laravel55
   cd laravel55
   composer require delatbabel/elocryptfive
   php artisan make:auth
   php artisan migrate:fresh

   (if there is an error with key length, change encoding values in config/database.php to 'utf8' and 'utf8_general_ci' accordingly)

2. Add below to app/User.php:

use Delatbabel\Elocrypt\Elocrypt;

class User extends Authenticatable
{
    use Elocrypt;

   [...]

   protected $encrypts = [ 'name', ];

   [...]

• add provider to ``config/app.php

3. Test in tinker:

>>> User::create(['name' => 'test', 'email' => 'test@example.com', 'password' => Hash::make('test')]);

The value for name is encrypted.

>>> User::find(1)->update(['email' => 'example@example.com']);

After the update table preview shows data as unecrypted.

[dokicro]

Hey, I have the same problem did you found any solutions?

[bjauy]

Yes, you need to override getDirty() method in your models which depend on Elocrypt trait:

public function getDirty()
{
    $dirty = [];

    foreach ($this->attributes as $key => $value) {
        if (! $this->originalIsEquivalent($key, $value)) {
                    $dirty[$key] = $value;
        }
    }

    return $dirty;
}

[dokicro]

Thanks 👍

[delatbabel]

Hrm, interesting. I wonder if it can be over-ridden in the trait and if doing so will cause breakages on prior versions of Laravel? I haven't started migrating any projects to L5.5 yet although it's a planned change with the new LTS release. I will keep this ticket open for monitoring and if anyone has any further information.

[bjauy]

IIRC originalIsNumericallyEquivalent method was renamed (and refactored) to originalIsEquivalent in L5.5, so simply adding getDirty would break the trait for users of older versions.

Maybe we could just add second, optional trait with just getDirty() overriden? This, and an information in the readme should be enough IMHO.

Users of older Laravel versions wouldn't be affected by the changes.

I can prepare pull request if you don't mind and if the change is ok for you.

[schonhose]

I just want to chime in that I am also looking to migrate from Laravel 5.1 to 5.5. I use this package to encrypt data in my database so I welcome any ideas on how to make it work on 5.5.

[mrgrain]

There is also an other bug with Laravel 5.5: If an attribute is casted, the getDirty will fail as well in certain cases. Essentially Laravel is casting the encrypted values which will result in different encrypted values being regarded as the same. E.g. object, array or json will be tried to be read from JSON. However, since the provided input is encrypted, the casted value evaluates to false no matter what.

Our solution is to overwrite the castAttribute method

    /**
     * Decrypt encrypted data before it is processed by cast attribute
     * @param $key
     * @param $value
     *
     * @return mixed
     */
    protected function castAttribute($key, $value)
    {
        return parent::castAttribute($key, $this->doDecryptAttribute($key, $value));
    }

[delatbabel]

Thanks for the information. I'm continuing to track this. I'm about to migrate one project from 5.1 LTS to 5.5 LTS so I will try to build something that works for both LTS versions.

[mrgrain]

Instead of trying to fix it for both versions at the same time (or forks or whatever), @delatbabel you could just release a new version which requires Laravel 5.5

[mbardelmeijer]

@delatbabel any update on this?

[austinheap]

I ended up 1) forking this, 2) fixing all the Laravel 5.5 issues, 3) dropping support for Laravel below 5.5, and 4) a bunch of random cleanup & unit tests. Available below:

• https://github.com/austinheap/laravel-database-encryption
• https://packagist.org/packages/austinheap/laravel-database-encryption

[ITwrx]

@mrgrain where should one override the castAttribute method? thanks

[mrgrain]

@ITwrx Overwrite it in the model that needs to be encrypted. We have a base model for all encrypted models which uses Elocrypt's trait and overrides the castAttribute method (amongst other things).

Or you could simply create your own EncryptedModel trait which extends the original Elocrypt one.

[ITwrx]

@mrgrain cool, thanks.

[delatbabel]

Hi all, firstly sorry about the delay. I have had a long period of illness, just getting back to health now. I'll certainly look at integrating the patches into a Laravel 5.5 branch shortly.

[ITwrx]

glad you're back. stay well.