search

delftopenhardware / openhardwarenl

4 stars 1 forks source link

Open hardware challenge 2023 #5

Open SanliFaez opened 1 year ago

SanliFaez commented 1 year ago

To motivate and raise awareness about the value of open hardware, we can organize a national challenge in which student teams receive instruction and mentorship to tackle a challenging project, such as building a battery or contributing to the energy transition.

SanliFaez commented 1 year ago

@Delft-Open-Hardware can you please open another project to couple with all the issues regarding the OH challenge?

Vsaggiomo commented 1 year ago

Batteries may be too niche, though, and I'm not sure how many universities will participate

SanliFaez commented 1 year ago

I think Batteries, specially electrochemical ones are multi-disciplinary and a very good candidate for sciency project. TUE, TUD, RUG, UU, and UT will definitely participate, and perhaps some technical hoogscholen. Another similar project can be passive cooling. In general, I think connection with sustainability and energy will make such a project more attractive

Vsaggiomo commented 1 year ago

Yes, the TU ones and UU/RUG, where battery projects are already running. Doubt you'll get participants from WUR, UVA, VU, Rotterdam, Leiden, Maastricht, and Nijmegen... which incidentally are the ones you want to bring on board for OH.

I think there are two options: A free for all, like iGem, where the project have few restrictions on what and how to do it. Or a focused challenge, like SensUs, where you have a ton of restriction for developing a sensor.

SanliFaez commented 1 year ago

perhaps it is easier to decide based on a written draft for such a challenge. that will give us more info to decide upon, if such a decision is even necessary.

Jerzeek commented 1 year ago

@Delft-Open-Hardware can you please open another project to couple with all the issues regarding the OH challenge?

@santoshilam Will pick this up :)

SanliFaez commented 1 year ago

here's a first sketch for the FAIR battery challenge https://github.com/delftopenhardware/openhardwarenl/blob/position_paper/FAIRbattery_challenge.md

I posted it to trigger the discussion on assessing the open hardware challenges from the perspective of collaboration and usefulness, instead of merely performance. suggestions on evaluation and rewarding are especially welcome!