ark-show-vars doesn't work as expected

[gittes]

Do you require variables/facts to be in cache or have variables defined only in the inventory ini files?

When I have inventory files in it's own directory and group_vars directory with it's own files, atk-show-vars will only show me the heading lines with define group names.

What am I missing or doing wrong?

Below is output showing first the involved files, the involved files contents (host the same variable defined more than once) and then two sample outputs from ark-show-vars:

(ansible)christopherstewart ~/Temporary/ansible-toolkit-test ⚡ find . -type file ./development/stewness ./group_vars/all/proof ./group_vars/stewness_proof_all_dev ./group_vars/stewness_proof_all_nonprod ./group_vars/stewness_proof_web_dev ./host_vars/web003.dev.dc01 (ansible)christopherstewart ~/Temporary/ansible-toolkit-test ⚡ find . -type file | xargs -t -n1 cat cat ./development/stewness [stewness_proof_web_dev] web001.dev.dc01 web002.dev.dc01 web003.dev.dc01

[stewness_proof_app_dev] app001.dev.dc01 app002.dev.dc01 app003.dev.dc01

[stewness_proof_web_qa] web001.qa.dc01 web002.qa.dc01 web003.qa.dc01

[stewness_proof_app_qa] app001.qa.dc01 app002.qa.dc01 app003.qa.dc01

[stewness_proof_all_dev:children] stewness_proof_web_dev stewness_proof_app_dev

[stewness_proof_all_qa:children] stewness_proof_web_qa stewness_proof_app_qa

[stewness_proof_all_nonprod:children] stewness_proof_all_dev stewness_proof_all_qa cat ./group_vars/all/proof the_stewness: is all good cat ./group_vars/stewness_proof_all_dev the_stewness: 3 cat ./group_vars/stewness_proof_all_nonprod the_stewness: 101 cat ./group_vars/stewness_proof_web_dev the_stewness: 1 cat ./host_vars/web003.dev.dc01 the_stewnewss: about 3 (ansible)christopherstewart ~/Temporary/ansible-toolkit-test ⚡ atk-show-vars --inventory development app003.qa.dc01 Default Variables Group Variables (all) Group Variables (stewness_proof_all_nonprod) Group Variables (stewness_proof_all_qa) Group Variables (stewness_proof_app_qa) Host Variables Setup Cache Play Variables Play File Variables Role Variables Module Variables Variables Cache Role Parameters Extra Variables (ansible)christopherstewart ~/Temporary/ansible-toolkit-test ⚡ atk-show-vars --inventory development web003.qa.dc01 Default Variables Group Variables (all) Group Variables (stewness_proof_all_nonprod) Group Variables (stewness_proof_all_qa) Group Variables (stewness_proof_web_qa) Host Variables Setup Cache Play Variables Play File Variables Role Variables Module Variables Variables Cache Role Parameters Extra Variables

[gittes]

Bump.

Would love insight how group vars are processed and leverage this wonderful tool. Would help my team a lot.

[dellis23]

Sorry, for some reason I'm not getting notifications for this repo. I've tried "watching" this, so hopefully it will work in the future. I will take a look and follow up soon.

[dellis23]

If I had to guess based on the output, I would say it's because ansible toolkit expects your group and host variables to be inside the directory containing your inventory. In your case, this would look something like development/group_vars/, and development/host_vars. I believe I originally picked this pattern up from the suggested structure for Ansible Tower, but it's clear Ansible supports more ways of structuring these.

If you have time and are interested, I'd love if you could come up with a patch to support both cases. Otherwise, I'm not sure when I will be able to get to this. Either way, it's on my radar, so thank you for the issue.

[gittes]

Confirmed! I put copies of my host_vars and group_vars into my development/ inventory and it worked as expected.

I pretty swamped for time, but knowing the problem is, I will try to contribute a patch.

ansible 2.0 beta1 is out too... I wonder if we need to wait and see how it handles all this stuff too.

Thank you, and I'll contribute what I can.