search

denoland / dotland

[Archived] deno.land website
https://deno.land
MIT License
957 stars 626 forks source link

Curation of /x ? #2080

Closed reviewher closed 2 years ago

reviewher commented 2 years ago

https://deno.land/x has third party modules. Of the top 5 listed, only two actually work with /x. In order:

Does not work: https://deno.land/x/lodash does not mention Deno at all, and the maintainers are not interested in adding Deno examples

Does not work: https://deno.land/x/dayjs does not mention Deno at all, and the recommendation is to use skypack

Works: https://deno.land/x/sheetjs README is not loading but the README has Deno examples

Does not work: https://deno.land/x/xstate does not mention Deno in the main README. There is a recipe that recommends skypack

Works: https://deno.land/x/corejs README has a Deno example.

If /x is intended as a host, it does not make sense to highlight modules that do not actually use or recommend /x.

crowlKats commented 2 years ago

Works: https://deno.land/x/sheetjs README is not loading but the README has Deno examples

We have a max README filesize, and sheetjs is exceeding that.

The registry is not curated, and the main list goes by starcount.

crowlKats commented 2 years ago

Duplicate of #548

kitsonk commented 2 years ago

@lucacasonato and I have talked about improving the "scoring" of packages based on a defined set of criteria. I realise there is no issue for that. I will open one, but to be clear, deno.land/x doesn't curate nor "recommend" packages.

kitsonk commented 2 years ago

Ref #2081

ayoreis commented 2 years ago

The reason they don't mention or even work in Deno is explained here: https://stackoverflow.com/a/69483910/16342352