denoland / wanted_modules

Is there a missing deno module that is preventing you from building something? Let us know here.
https://deno.land/x
46 stars 2 forks source link

[Meta] reduce "conversion projects" in regards to deno #76

Open LeoDog896 opened 1 year ago

LeoDog896 commented 1 year ago

Given the rise of support in NPM compatibility, it feels a bit silly to entertain requests that are mainly about converting Y to Deno, when those types of issues should either be given to the original NPM module, or reported as issues for either Deno's npm compatibility library or esm.sh/similar vendors.

Instead, wanted modules should primarily be:

A lot of the conversations in the repository usually boil down to:

  1. "I need from NPM, since doesn't work." (usually these issues were reported before the full adoption of npm compatibility)
  2. Another user (or the same user) would usually either: a. Recommend a different approach, or link it to the repo to add Deno compatibility b. Find a workaround for their issue

The purpose of the repository is very nice (as it allows developers to find new ideas for Deno projects), but the redundancy of (very) big library ports in the face of Deno's NPM compatibility seems to be fit for reporting another repository (e.g. the recommended deno_std).