ZLYA VAC Review (DR1)

[dylanagreen]

Draft directory:/global/cfs/cdirs/desi/users/abrodze/QSOredshiftsY1/zlya-QSO-DR1-v0 1 catalog file, 3 files total

Initial Checks:

• [x] Includes README
• [x] Columns in ALLCAPS
• [x] Extension names in ALLCAPS
• [ ] Files include units

Initial Notes:

• Can you draft a short (~1-2 paragraph) summary of the VAC to include in the DR1 paper? For an example of what this would look like you can look at section 3.3.6 of the EDR paper (https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06308).
• It looks like you have an .ipynb_checkpoints folder in your VAC directory, unless we need it I think we should delete it
• If possible can you propagate the degree units to the catalog (as outlined in the README)?
• No comments on the README at this time except to include paper links when they're available, although in the near future it'll need to be reformatted to match desidatadocs.

[abrodze]

Thanks for the review. The checkpoint file has been deleted and units are added. Text for the DR1 paper will be emailed.

[abrodze]

updated version directory: /global/cfs/cdirs/desi/users/abrodze/quasarsY1/Y1-catalogs/VACs/zlya-QSO-DR1-v1

edit (4/16): v2 adds an additional column: /global/cfs/cdirs/desi/users/abrodze/quasarsY1/Y1-catalogs/VACs/zlya-QSO-DR1-v2