dessalines / thumb-key

A privacy-conscious Android keyboard made for your thumbs
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
1.04k stars 221 forks source link

Update claims about privacy #1009

Closed KTibow closed 3 months ago

KTibow commented 3 months ago

Describe your suggested feature

Right now, the points about predictive text in the README overgeneralize. They don't apply to all readers:

I would recommend changing them to focus on specific examples, like how SwiftKey personalizes ads with your data or how Samsung sends data to market research firms, instead of hyperboles like "phone keyboards are keyloggers" or "if it has predictive text, it's profit-driven and privacy-offending".

Other details

IMO discussions are better hosted on a platform that doesn't require manual approval

Acknowledgements

dessalines commented 3 months ago

None of the points apply to Gboard. It uses federated learning, so it can only learn a phrase if hundreds use it. Each user's update can't be inspected or identified.

According to who, google? Can you link the source code to prove this? If you're going to link to google's public docs, that counts as "just trust us".

You can open a PR to give some concrete examples of keylogging, but unless you work at google or one of these companies, and want to link the gboard source code to prove that its not keylogging, I'm not going to trust it.