search

developit / redaxios

The Axios API, as an 800 byte Fetch wrapper.
https://npm.im/redaxios
Apache License 2.0
4.67k stars 100 forks source link

Axios is adding a fetch adapter natively. Will Redaxios have any use then? #93

Closed nickchomey closed 1 year ago

nickchomey commented 1 year ago

This PR seems close to completion for adding a Fetch Adapter. https://github.com/axios/axios/pull/5146

Will there be any need/use-case for Redaxios then? It seems like it would still be lighter-weight - is that because Redaxios is just pure Fetch, while Axios + Fetch Adapter would still have all of the XHR stuff built-in?

Thanks!

rschristian commented 1 year ago

Indeed, even with the adapter redaxios should continue to be much lighter than axios.

There is a bit of a feature difference between the two, axios provides a number of helpers and some data manipulation that will be carried over to the new fetch implementation from the sounds of it.

redaxios is (for some) a more comfortable API for interacting with fetch() while axios on the other hand is a bit more of an opinionated helper for making requests.

nickchomey commented 1 year ago

Thanks! Yeah, I came to realize that redaxios isn't really axios with fetch, but just fetch with axios' api/interface. It doesn't appear to have interceptors, for example - despite there seeming to be an outstanding PR for it.

In all likelihood I'll end up using ofetch or wretch for my project - fetch with some axios-like features.