deviceplug / btleplug

Rust Cross-Platform Host-Side Bluetooth LE Access Library
Other
812 stars 147 forks source link

Android StartScan call can throw unhandled NullPointerException #375

Open qdot opened 7 months ago

qdot commented 7 months ago

Finally got a logcat from someone seeing crashes on Android when trying to start a bluetooth scan.

03-25 09:45:12.943 27456 27563 F ntiface_centra: thread.cc:2477] No pending exception expected: java.lang.NullPointerException: Attempt to invoke virtual method 'void android.bluetooth.le.BluetoothLeScanner.startScan(java.util.List, android.bluetooth.le.ScanSettings, android.bluetooth.le.ScanCallback)' on a null object reference
03-25 09:45:12.943 27456 27563 F ntiface_centra: thread.cc:2477]   at void com.nonpolynomial.btleplug.android.impl.Adapter.startScan(com.nonpolynomial.btleplug.android.impl.ScanFilter) (Adapter.java:9)
03-25 09:45:12.943 27456 27563 F ntiface_centra: thread.cc:2477] 
0

It looks like something in this line is causing this issue:

BluetoothAdapter.getDefaultAdapter().getBluetoothLeScanner().startScan(filters, settings, this.callback);

Most likely, getDefaultAdapter() is returning null here for some reason, but I'm not sure why. Unfortunately, since our Android code runs without a context, we can't check for system service status before trying this either.

At minimum, we should at least check for null on both the adapter and scanner objects, and throw with a relevant message. Ideally though, it'd be nice to figure out why we're not able to fetch an adapter here.

Gibbz commented 6 months ago

Sorry to hijack the thread. How do you setup the android permissions? I've got the startscan working on desktop, but android nothing happens for me. And android never asked for Bluetooth permission.

qdot commented 6 months ago

@Gibbz Required permissions are listed in the app manifest: https://github.com/intiface/intiface-central/blob/main/android/app/src/main/AndroidManifest.xml

And we ask for them on startup: https://github.com/intiface/intiface-central/blob/main/lib/intiface_central_app.dart#L178

Vollbrecht commented 3 weeks ago

Maybe just and oddity, though i want to mention it. Disclaimer: Not to familiar with the android java bluetooth api.

We are using two different types of Adapter Api. In the Peripheral.java class we are using the BluetoothAdapter.getAdapter() api that is newer and was introduced in API version 18, while in the Adapter.java class we always use BluetoothAdapter.getDefaultAdapter(). That one is older and was deprecated i think in API version 31.

wuwbobo2021 commented 2 weeks ago

"our Android code runs without a context"

Is this crate helpful? https://docs.rs/ndk-context/latest/ndk_context/struct.AndroidContext.html#method.context

It might work with j4rs as well: https://github.com/astonbitecode/j4rs/issues/121

qdot commented 2 weeks ago

Yeah I've got something filed to move to j4rs, it's just going to take more work than I've had time for lately. https://github.com/deviceplug/btleplug/issues/376