Edits checklist - Githubissues

diazrenata / scadsanalysis

Research compendium comparing species abundance distributions to their feasible sets.

MIT License

0 stars 0 forks source link

Edits checklist #49

Closed diazrenata closed 3 years ago

diazrenata commented 3 years ago

Main text

[x] Description of sampling algo in methods
[x] Format in text refs
[x] Word counts
[x] Nb of refs
[x] Nb of figs

Refs

[x] Citing data as from Baldridge (2016)?
[x] Format refs section
[x] Reference for Misc Abund database (formatting)

Supplements

[x] Edits to S1
[x] Edits to S2
[x] Check supplements for refs
[x] Supplemental figure legends
[x] Supplemental table captions
[ ] Add sampling algorithm as supplement (will change numbering)

Submission periphera

[x] Cover letter refs - see McGill 2007 for examples
[x] Conflicted/suggested reviewers
[x] Data availability statement (see above about citing Baldridge (2016) data, coming from GitHub but also downloadable from Zenodo... https://github.com/weecology/sad-comparison; https://zenodo.org/record/166725.)

diazrenata commented 3 years ago

Prior to submitting

[ ] incorporate Hao's edits
[ ] add algorithm supplement & renumber
[ ] add links to Zenodo download to filtering vignette
[ ] mention biorxiv in cover letter
[ ] HY, SKME sign off on final version
[ ] biorxiv upload
[ ] submit

Some decisions

Not doing badges
Will do transparent review
Not recommending reviewers

After submitting notes

Keep preprint updated with new versions
When ready to archive on Zenodo, include language that this data is provided for reproducibility, but that for other uses it is best to access from original sources.