Closed santiagohermo closed 11 months ago
Per call @diegogentilepassaro @gabrieleborg
I was thinking about our discussion the other day @diegogentilepassaro @gabrieleborg, about restructuring the paper in light of the comments we got. This is my plan:
It should be a nice empirical paper. Given the comments we got, I think we need better rents data and a GE model to go beyond this.
I think we can also change the title lower our claim of generality (removing the "place-based policies" part). Some ideas, with the help of chatGPT, that I liked
My favorite alternative title @diegogentilepassaro @gabrieleborg
From Workplace to Homeplace: The Ripple Effect of Minimum Wage Policies on Local Rental Housing Markets
I was thinking about our discussion the other day @diegogentilepassaro @gabrieleborg, about restructuring the paper in light of the comments we got. This is my plan:
- Rewrite the intro saying that the paper is about the spillover effects of the MW within the city, and how the residence and workplace MW helps us estimate that.
- Stress the importance of commuting patterns and of granular and high-frequency data for our research question. Drop the estimates using county and year variations.
- Frame the estimates of the "share pocketed" as an illustration of the importance of commuting patterns.
It should be a nice empirical paper. Given the comments we got, I think we need better rents data and a GE model to go beyond this.
Totally agree with this :D
My favorite alternative title @diegogentilepassaro @gabrieleborg
From Workplace to Homeplace: The Ripple Effect of Minimum Wage Policies on Local Rental Housing Markets
It is my favorite too, and the paper needs some rebranding! However, I think it should be: From Homeplace To Workplace: The Effect of Minimum Wage Policies on Local Rental Housing Markets
Two small changes!
Thanks @diegogentilepassaro!
Let us know what you think @gabrieleborg !
Thanks @diegogentilepassaro!
- I'm good with dropping "Ripple". We could also use "spillover", as in "The Spillover Effects of Minimum Wage Policies on Local Rental Housing Markets"
- I think that "From Workplace to Homeplace" better illustrates the idea that the MW shock originates in the workplace and ends up affecting the residence, so I would keep them in this order.
@santiagohermo I like the spillover word there! As for the other, now I understand why the "From Workplace to Homeplace", I was interpreting "From Homeplace to Workplace" as a statement about the MW metric that you should use. It use to be Homeplace now it is Workplace! haha Happy to stick to your choice. One small comment: should we stop calling it residence MW and change to homeplace then? or maybe change the title to "From Residence to Workplace"?
Hey @santiagohermo, I like the new title using the "spillover" word! that's good to me - it better frame the scope of the paper after the latest edits. Green light from my side! @diegogentilepassaro I didn't follow your last comment on the MW rebranding - are you suggesting to shift to "homeplace" to be more in line with workplace? My only fear is that the title then it'd become a bit too repetitive as the words really sounds very similar, so in that sense I'd keep residence. But if you both agree on changing it let's do it!
Thanks @gabrieleborg! The title page is looking something like this: https://github.com/diegogentilepassaro/min_wage_rent/issues/267#issuecomment-1619143021
A submission checklist for the Journal of Urban Economics is here. We need to review this before submitting
main
@diegogentilepassaro @gabrieleborg! Before closing this issue I wil:@santiagohermo my comments for the new draft are below: min_wage_rent_JUE_DGP.pdf
Thank you very much for all of the super hard work ❤️
I implemented some of your suggestions in the commit above @diegogentilepassaro !
This is an issue to track the review of the paper.