digidem / comapeo-core

A local-first library for collaborating on mapping projects
MIT License
8 stars 1 forks source link

Self-hosted server host / url requirements #885

Open gmaclennan opened 2 weeks ago

gmaclennan commented 2 weeks ago

Description

For a user to add an archive server (self-hosted server for syncing with CoMapeo over the internet), they need to enter a server address. This issue is to define what the requirements for the server address are. Proposal:

  1. The address that the user enters does not need to include a protocol (e.g. https://)
  2. If the user does enter a protocol, then it must be https://
  3. Server address may include a port and a path.
  4. For websocket connections, a server address with https:// should map to wss://, and http:// to ws://. Unencrypted protocols should only be allowed with dangerouslyAllowInsecureConnections.

Questions:

  1. Should the backend or frontend be responsible for parsing the URL to check if it's valid? Maybe both?
EvanHahn commented 2 weeks ago

I basically agree.

The frontend should:

The backend should:

I wrote the frontend's URL normalization logic here: https://github.com/digidem/comapeo-mobile/pull/779