Open rudokemper opened 1 month ago
/review
⏱️ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 3, because the PR introduces significant changes to the environment configuration and service definitions in Docker, which requires careful review to ensure compatibility and security. The addition of new services and environment variables increases the complexity of the review. |
🧪 Relevant tests | No |
⚡ Possible issues | Possible Security Issue: The PR introduces new environment variables for Azure storage and Mapbox without default values, which could potentially be misconfigured or expose sensitive data if not handled properly. |
Possible Configuration Error: The `DB_PORT` for the `map-packer` service is set to 8083, which is typically used for HTTP traffic and might conflict with other services. | |
🔒 Security concerns | Sensitive information exposure: The PR includes API keys and database credentials in the environment variables, which could be exposed if the Docker configuration or the environment is not secured properly. |
relevant file | balena.yml |
suggestion | Ensure that sensitive information such as `AZURE_STORAGE_CONNECTION_STORAGE_KEY` and `VUE_APP_PLANET_API_KEY` are not hardcoded or exposed in the configuration files. Consider using environment variables or secrets management solutions to handle sensitive data securely. [important] |
relevant line | - AZURE_STORAGE_CONNECTION_STORAGE_KEY: |
relevant file | docker-compose.yml |
suggestion | Modify the `DB_PORT` for the `map-packer` service to use a more appropriate port that is not typically used for other common services to avoid potential conflicts. [important] |
relevant line | DB_PORT: 8083 |
relevant file | docker-compose.yml |
suggestion | Consider adding a volume for the `map-packer` service to persist data if necessary, similar to other services to ensure data durability across container restarts. [medium] |
relevant line | volumes: |
relevant file | docker-compose.yml |
suggestion | Review and ensure that the `DATABASE_URL` environment variable is updated across all services that depend on the database to reflect the new database service name change from `terrastories-db` to `database`. [important] |
relevant line | - database |
/improve
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Pin the version of
___
**Consider pinning the version of | 9 |
Specify a more precise node version to enhance reliability___ **Use a more specific node version instead of the latest major release to avoid potentialincompatibilities with newer versions. This change enhances the reliability of the setup.** [.github/actions/deploy-balena-image/action.yml [53]](https://github.com/digidem/edt-offline/pull/64/files#diff-aede1820b7aac4441b076aa744ec22c8365ebaf3a2489ee6886fc6abf03186daR53-R53) ```diff -node-version: '20' +node-version: '20.x' ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Using a more specific node version (e.g., '20.x') instead of just '20' can prevent potential incompatibilities with newer versions, enhancing the reliability of the setup. | 8 | |
Security |
Provide default values or secure handling for environment variables___ **It's recommended to provide default values for environment variables or ensure they aresecurely managed if they are sensitive. This prevents potential runtime errors and security vulnerabilities.** [balena.yml [60-61]](https://github.com/digidem/edt-offline/pull/64/files#diff-8448e809945865b05ca68634bac731b7197e4631eebe6531f849cb56918e6908R60-R61) ```diff -- AZURE_STORAGE_CONNECTION_ACCOUNT_NAME: -- AZURE_STORAGE_CONNECTION_STORAGE_KEY: +- AZURE_STORAGE_CONNECTION_ACCOUNT_NAME: default_account_name +- AZURE_STORAGE_CONNECTION_STORAGE_KEY: ${AZURE_STORAGE_KEY} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Providing default values or ensuring secure management of environment variables can prevent runtime errors and security vulnerabilities. However, the suggested default values should be carefully chosen to avoid introducing security risks. | 7 |
Change the database port to avoid conflicts and enhance security___ **Ensure that the database port does not conflict with other services and consider using anon-default port for enhanced security.** [docker-compose.yml [108]](https://github.com/digidem/edt-offline/pull/64/files#diff-e45e45baeda1c1e73482975a664062aa56f20c03dd9d64a827aba57775bed0d3R108-R108) ```diff -- 5432:5432 +- 5433:5432 ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Changing the database port can help avoid conflicts with other services and enhance security. However, this change should be carefully coordinated to ensure it does not disrupt existing configurations. | 6 |
n/t