dingfengshi / TriDet

[CVPR2023] Code for the paper, TriDet: Temporal Action Detection with Relative Boundary Modeling
MIT License
160 stars 13 forks source link

about the mean average precision (mAP) results for thumos14 #11

Closed Beatricehuihuihui closed 1 year ago

Beatricehuihuihui commented 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for releasing the code! I reproduce directly for thumos14 dataset, but the mAP is a bit lower than yours, below is the result. Do you know why this happens? last_ep_result

dingfengshi commented 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for releasing the code! I reproduce directly for thumos14 dataset, but the mAP is a bit lower than yours, below is the result. Do you know why this happens? last_ep_result

Hi, it seems that different GPUs may produce different results. We conducted our experiments on different DGX-A100 machines and obtained the same results as those presented in our paper. We also tried a V100 GPU, which produced slightly lower results than the A100. There are similar phenomena in some other tasks. We don’t know the cause of the problem. It may be caused by the precision of different GPUs.

ClancyAyres commented 1 year ago

Hello, can I discuss with you the precautions when this code is reproduced, the mAP result on my side is lower

Beatricehuihuihui commented 1 year ago

Hello, can I discuss with you the precautions when this code is reproduced, the mAP result on my side is lower

Hi, I don't change anything in the code , just run it on a Tesla V100 GPU.

dingfengshi commented 1 year ago

Hello, can I discuss with you the precautions when this code is reproduced, the mAP result on my side is lower

Hi, I don't change anything in the code , just run it on a Tesla V100 GPU.

Hi, I guess because the THUMOS dataset is relatively small and action intensive for each video, the result is more affected by GPU accuracy. Can you try training on a larger dataset (like HACS)? My experience is that this dataset is less sensitive to various parameters and may be less influenced by the device and environment.

dingfengshi commented 1 year ago

Hello, can I discuss with you the precautions when this code is reproduced, the mAP result on my side is lower

Hi! feel free to email me your contact information to discuss this!