dingo35 / SmartEVSE-3.5

Smart Electric Vehicle Charging Station (EVSE)
MIT License
38 stars 13 forks source link

Mains Meter issues affect Normal charging, but config is hidden while in Normal charging mode #80

Closed thmjanssen closed 1 month ago

thmjanssen commented 1 month ago

Bit of a corner case, but I ran into the following as I was swapping my mains meter hardware:

If you have the following setup:

and then in either order:

the smartEVSE stops working with Communication Error as a result, but the Mains Meter setting is not visible in the Menu. If you want to remove the Mains Meter setting, you first need to switch back to Smart Mode, remove the Mains Meter setting and then switch back to normal.

Expected behaviour: I would expect the SmartEVSE to "just" charge in Normal mode, and completely disregard if the Mains Meter feed is working or not. Maybe report the Mains Meter issue in the UI, but not block charging because of it.

dingo35 commented 1 month ago

A lot of people use their SmartEVSE as a gateway from/to modbus and HomeAssistant, even in Normal mode

They hate having "blank" or incorrect values in their logs.

So you either configure a MainsMeter and provide the data, or you disable it.

We made this behaviour on user request Ping ponging hence and forth between opposite use cases seems pointless....