search

discord / discord-api-docs

Official Discord API Documentation
https://discord.com/developers/docs/intro
Other
6k stars 1.26k forks source link

Application does not exist after creation #7138

Open jstowey opened 2 months ago

jstowey commented 2 months ago

Description

When creating a new application in the Discord Developer Portal, the application does not exist after the initial creation.

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Click "New Application"
  2. Enter application name and accept terms and conditions
  3. Click "Create"
  4. Try to update one of the fields
  5. See "Unknown Application" error

Expected Behavior

The application should not be removed as soon as it's been created.

Current Behavior

The application doesn't exist straight after creation.

Screenshots/Videos

https://www.awesomescreenshot.com/video/31419639?key=e85ce76a92142baeba6bbc2b1504be4d

Client and System Information

OS: Kubuntu (22.04) Browser: Firefox Developer Edition (131)

aamiaa commented 2 months ago

https://github.com/discord/discord-api-docs/issues/6960#issuecomment-2207381994

JustinBeckwith commented 2 months ago

Confirmed, we will remove apps if you name them after a very popular, known app.

AlmostSuspense commented 2 months ago

so why not just show a helpful error message instead?

JustinBeckwith commented 2 months ago

I agree that would be better, it's just work that we haven't prioritized yet.

jstowey commented 2 months ago

Okay I understand that and that makes total sense, but I'm having the same problem even when naming the bot something completely unrelated

edwinmp commented 1 month ago

I've tried a few seemingly random names and none have stuck.

aamiaa commented 1 month ago

It's an anti abuse behavior which can trigger even if you don't impersonate any app. If it keeps happening to you, the only thing you can really do is copy the bot's id and submit an appeal at https://dis.gd/request, like suggested by staff in the comment I've linked above.

edwinmp commented 1 month ago

I left it alone overnight and then tried my preferred name the next day. It worked fine.

TolgaYigit commented 1 month ago

This issue still present. I tried many different random app names.

juanibe commented 1 month ago

Any other solution to this issue?.

Update: Using a different email account worked. So in some cases it might be related to that.

manishh commented 1 month ago

How to get this working?

Even an application created with unique (not-spam) name gets deleted without any informative message. :(

LazyTarget commented 1 month ago

This is completely broken. It seems implossible to create a new app at this moment I've tried everything from a generic descriptive names to random number sequences and password generators.

josh-hogle commented 1 month ago

I'm having the same issue. It's a bit crazy that there's not even a message that gets displayed. That should literally take like less than an hour to code into the product instead of just randomly deleting the app. I just wasted an hour trying to figure out what was going on because of the lack of a simple message.

I was hoping to create a custom app but now I'm not even sure if I want to waste any more time on this.

zimpzon commented 3 weeks ago

Same issue still. Just trying to create an app, but it is silently deleted immediately. This shows as 'Unknown Application' when trying to update it.

norelleliang commented 3 weeks ago

Same thing happens here, this is very weird. I tried different names, different browsers, every time I created an app go to the bot section to get the token it shows "unknown application", and I have to refresh, once refreshed, the whole app is gone and I have to recreate one and every changes I make it is the same thing - "unknown application" - app gone, nothing is working, this is getting frustrating.

juanibe commented 3 weeks ago

I found a workaround by using a different account (used my personal gmail instead of the one provided by my job). Chaning my email account worked. I have no idea the reasons though.

zimpzon commented 3 weeks ago

I found a workaround by using a different account (used my personal gmail instead of the one provided by my job). Chaning my email account worked. I have no idea the reasons though.

Before trying your solution I tried again with the same account I used yesterday, and now it worked! I didn't switch to another account.

atbe commented 3 weeks ago

Happening to me too, so so frustrating considering the apps just "disappear"

BladeMF commented 3 weeks ago

My apps keep disappearing as well. Sometimes they stick until a put a photo or interactions link and then they disappear.

Goodyear1555 commented 3 weeks ago

Same issue here...unable to add an application. As soon as you want to save a change: Unknown Application

thathurtabit commented 3 weeks ago

I think this has been broken for a least a few months. I remember trying a while ago and today I'm getting the same error "Unknown Application" when I try to save a new OAuth app.

PATCH https://discord.com/api/v9/applications/1304742778923778048 404 (Not Found)

discord

jozzert commented 2 weeks ago

Same issue, after approximately 10s the app (lots of different names tried) is deleted, leading to 'Unknown Application' error when trying to edit.

nonstopdevelopment commented 2 weeks ago

Yeah still happening. Been dealing with the issue that the app is created and then goes away. Happens right after the token reset action every time. Even tried naming dev bots to something like nsdtesting05 and still ends up getting deleted.

mishenThakshana commented 2 weeks ago

Yes still issue persists

MarinPostma commented 2 weeks ago

Same issue here. @JustinBeckwith any proposed workaround? (tagging since you reopened).

thebraino commented 2 weeks ago

Tried making various bots for my classroom. Same issue.

JustinBeckwith commented 2 weeks ago

There is no proposed workaround as of yet, but we are actively looking into the problem, and will get back to the thread this week.

e-lisa commented 2 weeks ago

Just wanted to confirm, application creation via https://discord.com/developers/applications is down hard. Applications are not created and user's are given "Unknown Application" if they try to save. Had multiple people try to create an application, all with the same error.

Hopefully someone will take this bug report seriously :pray:

I am unsure about the Application Name theory as even making a bot with the name of "sjdilfjldksfjldk" is deleted.

EDIT: It seems some accounts can create Applications, and some cannot. Unsure what the difference between these accounts is

MarinPostma commented 2 weeks ago

I created a new Gmail and signed up with that, and could create an app without any issue. It seems to be linked to the user rather than the app name?

e-lisa commented 2 weeks ago

I created a new Gmail and signed up with that, and could create an app without any issue. It seems to be linked to the user rather than the app name?

I tried the same thing and also was able to create an app. It seems like discord has a "magic" way they ban users from creating apps, with out reporting, explaining, or providing an appeal process. It is a very hostile environment to work in.

JustinBeckwith commented 2 weeks ago

Update for those affected - there are two separate issues at play.

  1. Last week we had an incident that caused unintentional deletion of a subset of apps. For most accounts, this should be resolved.
  2. For a smaller percentage of users - we are still working on surfacing errors when we delete apps intentionally. Usually this is related to scripting of app creation, account status/age, etc.

We're not fully resolved yet, but we're still working here. Thanks for bearing with us ❤️